Withings
Review
AI summary based on real user insights
The Withings Body Scan has a loyal core of fans, mostly long-time Withings users who value the ecosystem. They praise that it has a great app, and syncs with Apple Health , that Wi-Fi uploads mean I don't need my phone to weigh myself , and that the segmental readings are motivating. Even satisfied owners frame it as a trend tool: it will allow you to see overall trends rather than give exact numbers, and a few say it's been very accurate for me .
The majority of comments, however, are critical, and accuracy is the main reason. Several owners describe readings that change from one step to the next, with one saying it has never (even once) provided a repeatable body fat measurement . Compared with DEXA scans, results were off in both directions: some got implausibly low numbers such as Withings Body Scan tells me I have 3.5% fat , while others found it reads several points high. Heart rate is another weak spot, with owners calling it garbage for measuring your heart rate , which in turn makes ECG readings fail.
Reliability problems come up repeatedly. Some units stopped reading ANY health data beyond my weight after a year or more, others report a less than 10% success rate for body composition, and one buyer went through several replacements after the handle broke (would not retract) . Support draws heavy criticism, with owners saying they spent the entire time blaming me instead of fixing the scale. App sync can also lag, and one owner was upset when a feature was later placed behind a subscription . Owners who get consistent results stress a strict routine, such as measuring after a shower, before eating, with limbs apart.
On value, many feel the withings is too expensive for what you get , and some recommend a cheaper Withings scale instead. Buyers already in the Withings ecosystem who only want trend data tend to be happier, with one calling it a quality product and worth the cost , but anyone who needs dependable body-fat or heart numbers should expect frustration.
Sign in to leave a comment.