Withings
Review
AI summary based on real user insights
Fans of the Withings Body Comp like how easily it fits into a health-tracking setup: it uploads all the data to my apple health app each morning , connects to Whoop, and supports several family members, with one owner saying they support use by multiple users better than cheaper rivals. Several bought it for the extra metrics, such as the Pulse Wave Velocity / Vascular age feature or the nerve health feature, as I'm diabetic , and long-time users describe it as one of those things that just works .
Accuracy draws the most debate. Many owners treat it as a trend tool, saying the thing that mattered for me was the consistency and that relative % (eg gain/loss) seems accurate even when absolute numbers differ from a DEXA scan. Others are less forgiving: one found it 4% higher than the dexa , another returned it because Other than weight, the other options on the scale are inaccurate , and one owner says the body composition reading ends with an error most of the time.
Software is the other recurring complaint. Owners describe a continual struggle of the app syncing and not syncing with apple health , frequent resets and a clock that is always 1-2 days off in the date , and second-user data that seemed to require paying for a SECOND subscription . Support gets poor marks, with one owner saying Withing support is TERRIBLE .
On price, some accept that It's expensive, but it does sync with HealthKit , while others call Withings scales far too expensive for what they offer and say the cheaper Body Smart is enough unless you want vascular and nerve metrics, since the Comp wasn't worth twice the price . It suits Apple Health users who want consistent day-to-day trends rather than clinical-grade body fat numbers.
Sign in to leave a comment.