Weber
Review
AI summary based on real user insights
The Weber Smokey Mountain 18 is a favorite starter smoker, and owners say it is frankly hard to get bad results from . Many report long, stable cooks on one load of charcoal; one says controlling temps has been effortless , another that it runs 8-10 hours at 250 , and others describe holding within +-10 degrees of my target all day long . Owners also praise the cleanup, ease of use, and light weight aspect , and say the smoke ring and flavor rival bigger cookers (The smoke ring and flavor are spot on every time ).
It is also seen as very durable, with many owners serving me well for over a decade and noting replacement parts are readily available . Not everyone finds it easy, though: one long-time owner says it is still very difficult to regulate temperature , and others recommend door and lid seals because older units leak; one tip is to Flip the door upside down and it will seal better , while another notes you prob still have to fuss with it a bunch . A couple of sausage makers find it uneven for low-temperature smoking.
The most common regret is size. Owners describe kicking myself for not going with the 22 from the start , and with ribs I can only fit 3 flat without rolling or cutting them. Big briskets can be made to fit with tricks, so it suits small households and beginners best, while anyone cooking for groups is usually pointed toward the 22-inch.
Sign in to leave a comment.