Garmin
Review
AI summary based on real user insights
The Garmin Index S2 is bought almost entirely for one reason: it automatically sends the info to Garmin Connect with no manual logging, which many owners say is worth it if they already use a Garmin watch. Owners report it syncs perfectly with Garmin Connect , supports multiple users ( Everyone in my family can use it ), and that Battery life is really good . Weight itself is generally trusted: one says the weight measurements are very accurate , another that it is within a pound or two of the doctor 's scale.
Body composition is the dominant complaint. Many owners say the other metrics are all crap or that the other metrics on the S2 are seriously broken , with reports that its body fat % is terribly inaccurate against DEXA scans and that just by changing your age in Garmin connect you will get drastically different result . A minority found it close: one measured within 0.2% of what my Garmin S2 measured against a Bod Pod. Calibration helps some: you can get a DEXA scan after you get it so you can calibrate it , and one owner notes it is the only smart scale that allows you to input the results of a real test, but others found any sort of body recomposition is not picked up by the scale even after calibrating.
Reliability is uneven. Some owners describe it as literally 100% problem free , while others say mine always fails to connect , that It suddenly refused to connect to my wifi , or that connecting my Index S2 was a nightmare . Everyday use draws gripes too: It doesnt wake up when you step on it by design , the UI is incredibly laggy and unresponsive , and with two similar-weight users it fails to select the correct user . Several also note Garmin have not released an update to this scale in years.
On value, the consensus is that it is wildly overpriced for what it measures, with one owner calling it what essentially is a $20 scale plus Connect integration. Buyers who are deep in Garmin's ecosystem and only care about weight trends are the happiest, and several suggest waiting for a discount ( Id never pay MSRP for it ); one such owner says it is Worth the expense for that reason alone . If accurate body fat is your goal, most commenters say to look elsewhere.
Sign in to leave a comment.