What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
WithingsWithings Body SmartReddit score
82% positive · 70 opinions
WithingsWithings BodyReddit score
79% positive · 109 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Too close to call
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Auto Syncing
Syncing
Body Fat
Body Composition
Value
Weight Consistency
Weight Accuracy
Trend Tracking
App
Pairing Issues
Summary
The Withings Body Smart is widely recommended as a no-fuss Wi-Fi scale. Owners call it unbeatable for accuracy and repeatability on taking your weight, and one says the weight is spot on though when checked against medical visits. The biggest draw is syncing: because it uses Wi-Fi, I just step on it, walk away and the reading lands in the app, and it pairs with the Health app on my iPhone, Google Health Connect and Whoop, with one owner saying it integrated perfectly in to Whoop. Shared households like that it recognises who is standing on it.
The Withings scales are mostly praised for hands-off syncing: owners say you just stand on the scale and the reading lands over Wi-Fi in the Health Mate app, Apple Health, Google Fit, MyFitnessPal and other services. One owner of the basic Body says I would but it again, noting the batteries last about two years, while another switched from a Renpho and just works every time. Multi-user households like that it allows multiple users, and several people find the charted history keeps them calm because you can zoom out and see the long-term trend instead of daily swings.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Withings Body Smart
I've also been a FitBit user since 2014. I loved the logic and simplicity of the app, particularly when it was still available on laptop. Once it went to only app on phone I hated adjusting to it, but ultimately found all I was used to. I bought an Apple watch a few years back and hated it because it was too complicated and had a zillion features I would never use. Now Google has enshittified FB app in the same way. It reminds me of the Withings BodySmart scale app, which reports mostly calculations made after taking a basic weight reading, but that's buried in the fine print. Google did this to force people to rely on AI. In Google Workspace on laptop there are options for turning AI off, but I haven't found one in the new fitness app. Some of us actually like being able to get rid of tiles we don't want, track only what we want to know, and see computations that are based on real time data transferred from the device to the app. Sadly we are not the customers Google wants.
Got a withings body smart. Weigh myself every day to see the trend. I know it's inaccurate. Bought the same scale again for my gf house and well... The other one always has total different numbers. 1 pound difference and 3 to 5 % in bodyfat...
I have a Withings Body Smart - Advanced Body Composition Wi-Fi Scale. I got a Dexa scan a few weeks ago and it was 10 percentage points off on body fat/lean mass measurements, way underestimating my body fat percentage. I just bought a Hume Body Pod Scale which is supposed to be 97% accurate to a Dexa scan. Waiting for it to be delivered. They started their Black Friday sale early and you can get an extra 20% off with the code: LOWCARBLOVE.
Withings Body
I have a Withings Body+ and I would recommend against it or any Withings product. To connect them with the app, you need a Withings account, and measurements all get uploaded to their servers. If you give the app access to additional categories of health data stored on your phone, it will upload all that to their servers as well. Fortunately the app still works if you only grant access to the categories that the scale writes, reducing but not eliminating the violation of your privacy. The body fat percentage estimate it gives is not meaningful. Even averaging out the fluctuations due to hydration, which affect any bioelectrical impedance analysis measurement, the scale reports my body fat at 6% more than measured by DEXA. At low body fat, being off by 6% is a substantial error.
I have a Withings scale. I bought the most basic model, because BIA isn’t a very accurate way to estimate body composition. The scale is fine. It seems consistent, the hardware is nice quality, it stays connected to wifi… The Withings app is trash though. It’s cluttered, buries your weight data in a slew of Apple Health information that you are likely already viewing elsewhere with more clarity; it takes a fair amount of navigation to find a simple table of weights-in values, which is probably the primary information most people want to find in their scale app. The sync TO Apple Health (updating new weights) is also slow and idiosyncratic for some reason, although the Withings app seems to pulll down information from Apple Health instantaneously.
I had the Withings+ smart scale which did body fat and muscle percentage. It would be wildly different day-to-day.
Withings Body Smart
People tend to mainly complain online! The scale for me is best in class & body smart is great value for money. Withings have always been better at hardware than software mind you but overall it works really well. Syncs to Apple health as well if you’re an Apple user.
I don't own a Body Fit, but I've been around here long enough to comment on the other points. Generally, my view of Withings is positive. I have several devices from them: BPM Connect, BPM Vision, 2x Sleep Analyzers, 2x BeamO's, and a Body Smart scale. All perform well, except for the Connect. With some experimentation, I got it working well enough (it was giving absurdly high systolic measurements) after some experimentation. I've also participated in a video interview with their engineers in France, and found them to be genuinely concerned with how their products are viewed. A ton of bad feedback is on the new Body Scan 2. Here's a rundown of it and how it relates to the Body Fit: I have been looking seriously into getting the Body Scan 2, and this is where I've been getting more critical of Withings. They've flubbed the release pretty badly - the software appears to be in a early-mid beta cycle, and there may be an issue with the sensors in some of the scales (the 3% body fat issue). The Body Fit shares the same body composition technology as this scale, so you should be aware of the issue. The Fit also was released a while ago, and aside of some comments over how it isn't heavy and feels "cheap" there's not been much criticism of it - aside from the body fat issue I mentioned previously and how well it measures up to DEXA scans. For some - it's excellent. For others, not so much. Withings, to their credit, is asking for DEXA results so they can better tune their algorithm. Some features are still not available on the BS2, though this may be due to regulatory issues and not technical ones. Any US Withings customer can tell you the FDA makes things difficult. The Body Fit does not appear to have any issues here. This BS2 is also the first product that had announced features locked behind a paywall, when no paywall was mentioned in the announcement. The Body Fit does not appear to have this issue. This has a bunch of people up in arms about it. Myself included. As for the Body Fit, it had a relatively quiet release and has been out for a couple months. The BS2 has seen multiple delays, and a release announcement for US users that was cancelled the next day under dubious reasons. I've also gotten several emails inviting me to order that have dead links. I've posted about them here. That's about as even-handed a response I can give. There are others here with axes to grind - they may have their reasons for their negative posts, but a lot of them are just "it's junk", "the algorithms are all BS", or "stay away". All I can say about these two new scales is they are currently working on improving them via software updates, are seeking feedback, and they have a history of updating their products and fixing bugs.
Vote Withings also. Got the same scales and also upgrades for the same one I think. Got 8 1/2 years of weight history from it.
Withings Body
I bought this scale when it was still WiThings. Very happy with it. Syncs with Health and, of course, via Health into other fitness apps like MyFitnessPal. Also allows multiple users, which is good for my wife and son so they can track too.
I step on a scale nearly every day and over the last 2 years I've dropped 120 pounds. It keeps my sanity in check because the withings scale will note down what the weight was and on what date in the app. When you inevitably weigh higher than the day before for whatever reason, you zoom out and see that you've lost 9 pounds over the last 30 days. You are immediately able to chill because you have charted active progress. It is very hard to remember what you weighed 30 days ago unless you note it down manually in an app or have something like a withings body+ like I have.
I really like my Withings Body. The body composition is a nice feature it works with just about any fitness tracker platform you choose, as well as HealthKit. It has a Watch app too, but it just displays your recent weight in and a graph of recent weigh-ins, Fat Mass, and BMI.