What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
WaterdropWaterdrop G3P600Reddit's pickReddit score
68% positive · 36 opinions
AquaTruAquaTru ClassicReddit score
60% positive · 31 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Water Quality
Durability
Taste
Water Waste
Maintenance
Support
TDS Reduction
Odor
Reliability
Installation
Summary
Owners of the Waterdrop G3 tankless RO system (mostly the G3P600 and G3P800) are largely happy with the water itself: many say the water tastes great, and TDS readings drop sharply, with one owner reporting Brought my TDS to 8-10 from 275. Because there is no tank, the water flows quickly. Most found the install was very straightforward, and filter changes are SUPER simple. A couple of people who tried Waterdrop's G5 side by side liked the water out of the g3p600 better, and several say the customer support is great.
Plenty of long-term owners like the AquaTru Classic countertop RO system, with several reporting five years or more of use and saying it still works like a champ. Fans call it worth every penny and like that it needs no plumbing, so renters brought it with me when I moved. On taste, owners say the water tastes great, and one buyer who lab-tested it against an iSpring found the Aquatru came back at 97 and that it dispenses water much quicker.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Waterdrop G3P600
Thanks for the reply. I ended up steering away from the hot water unit since I wanted RO run to the fridge. Then the unit I chose (G3P800) ended up having an internal leak 3 days in and now I’m waiting for a replacement. If that one leaks too I’m done with Waterdrop.
Waterdrop g3p600 - connected to fridge turns on and off I have a tee (T) connected on the output of my G3p600 one going to the faucet the other one going into the fridge - if I dispensing water from the fridge it turns on and off 😪 not a constant on. Works fine on the faucet.
I’ve had G3P600 for about 2 months. No complaints about the water quality but the constant flushing it does to clean itself is annoying and a huge waste of water. Even if you get 1/2 cup of water, it’s gonna go through the full flushing cycle. That’s dumb and $$ in wasted water. And when it’s flushing, it’s loud! Ways to mitigate: fill up your biggest water bottles once and use them throughout the day instead of opening the tap every single time you need water. The system will still flush itself even if you don’t open the tap all day but much less frequently.
AquaTru Classic
I just bought the Aqua Tru with minerals. The water smells like rotten eggs! Not cool. It is so gross. But I need the minerals. I feel like I've been tricked.
Not sure if you still need an answer. I recently purchased a AquaTru Classic/Connect. My experience after 10 gallons is in the 75-80% tds reduction. The problem is AquaTru website says their unit should be 90% reduction, under 80% reduction is a sign of filter change, but my unit is new. My best guess is either the filter they sent me is used or unit doesn't truly perform their marketing. note my VOC does NOT include added mineral. I'm interested to hear feedback on tds reduction in other brand Countertop RO in similar price ranges.
I had the same experience when I first got the AquaTru with the Alkaline filter. I was extremely excited for the new water filter and the taste was a major let down. After running a ton of water (almost 20 - 30 tanks) through the filter, the taste went away.
Waterdrop G3P600
We installed a Waterdrop G3P800 a couple of years ago and have been very happy with it. Its a little pricey but definitely worth it IMO. Haven't had any issues with it so far. I mostly like it because its super efficient - around 1 gallon wasted for every 3 gallons purified which as I understand is better than most. And the water flows quickly, nothing worse than having to wait 30 seconds to fill a glass of water. We did have to shell out an extra 30 bucks or something for the remineralization filter though which was a little annoying.
We recently installed the Waterdrop G3P600 under sink, tankless RO system. It was easy to install, but we needed someone to drill into our countertop for the faucet. We’re really happy with it. Our well water was fine, but we didn’t like the taste. Now, we love it.
I have a Waterdrop 800 G3P and I’m very impressed. The install was very straightforward and well explained, the construction is actually decent, and the customer support is great … I feel like that is rare for an appliance company these days
AquaTru Classic
Update: Aqua Tru has added a disclaimer and replaced my filters 🙏🏽🤍 I appreciate them and still love my AquaTru
Aquatru had mine about 5 years now. Works much better than the gravity fed filters.
Honestly, my only issue was them sending me the wrong filter then refusing to send the correct one. I was not going to give them anymore money and I wanted to try out the clearly filtered pitcher. I like it, but in my eyes the aquatru is a better deal and better tasting water