What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
SteelcaseSteelcase Leap V2Reddit's pickReddit score
93% positive · 102 opinions
SteelcaseSteelcase AmiaReddit score
91% positive · 37 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Too close to call
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Comfort
Used Value
Durability
Lumbar Support
Seat Cushion
Sitting Freedom
Back Support
Armrests
Build Quality
Tailbone Pain
Summary
The Steelcase Leap V2 is one of the most praised office chairs in these discussions. Owners call it the most comfortable chair I have used ever and say it is an Absolute dream to sit in even across 8–12 hour days. Several people who tried a Herman Miller Aeron preferred the Leap because there is less hard plastic to interact with pressure points, and it tolerates sitting in odd positions: One leg tucked under, leaning hard to the left. People moving from gaming chairs often report that It has made a huge difference in stiffness and pain.
The Steelcase Amia gets a lot of quiet loyalty. Owners call it my fave chair of all times, and several say it handles very long days: one tall, heavy owner reports I spend 12+ hours a day in it without soreness. The seat is the most praised part, with people describing the seatpan is amazing, and the armrests, which are basically the same as the Leap, also get good marks. It is described as the good ol reliable with solid build quality, and it suits a wide range of bodies, from a 5'3" buyer who calls it good for small people to owners over six feet.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Steelcase Leap V2
I started the Chair hunting journey when I realized that my physical discomforts were making me less productive. Mainly my back, I was leaning forward too much. and when I lean back, the back support for my old chairs were so bad that it would make me want to lean forward again. I started off with a typical leather chair that lasted me a few years. And looking back, ignorance was bliss. I wasn't aware of how much it was uncomfortable until the last moment when I realized it. Once I started doing research on office chairs, I couldn't look back. I was on the hunt for a chair that I can sit in and not remember I was sitting on a chair, which will allow me to fully focus on my work. I was looking for the perfect chair. I have tried a whole bunch of chairs, and have lost Thousands of dollars at this point looking for it. I rationalized, Telling myself that this is an investment for my future and my health long term, and once I solve this problem, It'll be worth it. I've tried the Steelcase Leap v2 - Lumbar support hurts okay next up Herman Miller Aeron - Trapped me in the chair, the sides dug into my thighs I've tried to Herman Miller Embody - The lumbar support was too hard and hurt my back I've tried a bunch of Amazon Ergonomic Chairs, Which ultimately led to returns and frustrations. Knoll Generation Chair, Boss Chair, Task Chairs, Gaming Chair. I've tried so many. I've tried a bunch of 2nd tier Top office chairs like chairs from autonomous and etc. Although they look nice and has all type of bells and whistles, They weren't comfortable in the end. Out of all those chairs by that point, I ended up returning it or selling it at a lost. and I was frustrated sitting on a cheap $40 Task chair I bought from amazon. After that entire journey, the most comfortable one was a $40 task chair? And Even that chair was physically painful to sit in. But its was the best out of all of them. a $40 chair. Well, I did more research. And came across Joe Rogans Chair. the Hag Capisco. I've always had this chair in the back of head, and have came across it multiple times throughout my search but I wanted to try the top name chairs. the Herman millers. I saw a video of joe talking about how the chair has fixed his spine problems. And decided to buy it during thanksgiving black Friday discount sale. Well here's the review of it: It has solved the back problem. I don't feel any discomfort on my back at all. And I'm sitting straight. The seating i'm still getting used to. But to be honest, I am willing to trade the comfort of my butt than on my back. And the seating isn't that bad at all. The thigh problem i had on the herman miller aeron? Gone. Is this chair perfect? No. But it is the closest chair i have found. And honestly after trying out all the other chairs. I dont think i will ever find a perfect chair. But if i can find a close to perfect with slight compromises. I'm content. Thanks for reading my post! and if you have any questions let me know!
> If you consider the Millennials to be the "first generation of gamers", their price point totally makes sense. Adult gamers in their late 20s early 30s who are well into their careers, I feel personally attacked. /s I did just order a Mirra 2 brand new so yeah man, you fucking nailed it. Big streamers will buy this, some of them will be sent this from Logitech if sponsored. It'll probably be the chair that is used in every e-sport tournament (once the Big Rona settles down). This is a huge win for HM. The average gamer will not buy this. They will continue to buy Ikea Marcus's or <insert random racecar seat gamer chair> or budget office max chair every couple of years. Once they get into their 30's and 40's their back and posture will probably be shot. In the last 3 years I've had 6 chairs (2 sent back during the return period) to help me game longer with better comfort and all of them were not great. * DXRacer (too small, pinched my thighs) - $250 * DXRacer Titan (ironically too big and hard, crappy lumbar padding) - $400 * ION Ignition 2.0 (what i'm using now, it's ok for a few hours) - $330 * Used Herman Miller Celle (has 0 pad on the seat, but I cycle it in when my back hurts from the ION) - $300 * Autonomous Ergo Chair 2 (fucking awful) - $350 * Steelcase Leap V2 Refurb (hurt my legs and butt, back was good though) - $475 If the Mirra 2 doesn't work out for me, I'm definitely going to grab an Embody. Maybe it'll be this one, or maybe a regular one. Either way, I think there are many people like me that have the money and are tired of having a bad sitting experience while working from home and leisurely gaming at night.
I totally hear you. I have been on a new chair journey myself. I was previously using an IKEA Markus where the cushion have finally bottomed out after about 5 years--it now feels like sitting on rock and its caused extreme tailbone/sit bone/lower back pain. I have also recently lost weight and now suddenly, my sit bones are more sensitive and need proper support/cushioning. For reference, I'm 5'8" / 207 lbs. I'm a web developer and WFH and I'm also a gamer so I need something that is comfortable for loooong hours (8-12 hrs). Below are things that I have learned that I hope you will find helpful because I can relate with your situation: \- Online/Youtube reviews are helpful but take it with a grain of salt. I have watched reviews from BTOD, Ahnestly, random youtubers, etc. - I've learned that the high-end chairs they consider awesome are honestly overrated because its all personal preference and needs. What others think is comfortable or good may be the exact opposite for you. Learnings from chairs I've bought and tried: \- Mesh bottom chairs are not for me -- I tried the Colamy 5188/Aerix mesh chair and after using for several days, it still gave me sit bone and tailbone pain/soreness as well as leg pain because of the front foam that digs in to your thigh when you sink into the mesh after long hours. So even though many people love and praise a high-end chair like the HM Aeron, I know that it will feel like crap to me. But your experience may be different though--if you prefer mesh and a somewhat aggressive lumbar support, then I encourage you to try Colamy 5188/Aerix --its well built and my favorite features about it were the bread loaf style arm rests (similar to HM Aeron) --its soft, wide and has great adjustability--I wish all chairs has this arm rest. The built-in leg rest is also awesome--I loved using it when I had the chair. But again, mesh just wasn't for me. \- Cushioned seats seem to be best fit for me but it cannot be too firm. I bought the Colamy Atlas ($240) based on high praise from online reviews --guess what? The cushion was trash for me--its way too firm and also gave me butt pain. And in my opinion, the convex seat shape is also horrible because it caused my hips to be uneven which also caused me pain. \- I tried a BTOD refurbished Steelcase Leap V2 with the added foam ($640)--and guess what--its so freakin overrated! The seat was still way too firm for me and bottomed out on me --I also didn't like the slight lean on the back rest when on the upright locked position. I wanted to like this chair but I returned it after several days because I couldn't sit in it for more than 30 mins. \- I'm currently using the Colamy Neza (bought it for $220 on sale) -- I've been using it for a couple of days now and this one seems like a keeper! The seat has a flatter shape and the cushion has just the right amount of support and softness to where I can sit in it for long hours without any pain. The arm rest adjustments are perfect for my desk height too. It's well constructed and has a nice backrest and adjustable lumbar support. I was pleasantly surprised with this TBH because my expectations were really low for a chair at this price point but I really like it and it does not feel or look cheap--its very sturdy. The tile tension adjustment is also awesome--can be dialed in for higher tension unlike the Atlas. This uses the same adjustment mechanism found on more expensive chairs like the Branch Ergonomic Chair. I'm quite impressed so far. The only thing to note though is the Neza does not have a head rest. \- If you still feel like your butt needs more support without the pressure to your tailbone and sit bones, I HIGHLY recommend the Purple Cushion Ultra or Double --yes its expensive but very worth it. I used this as an interim solution for when I had the Atlas and Ikea chairs and they were game changers. I'm currently not using it because the Neza seat seems to be working well for me but I'm keeping the cushion just in case. Just note that these cushions elevate you when seated so just adjust your seat and armrest height accordingly and you should be good. \- Bottom line, reviews are a good guide but try the chairs out yourself and return if it doesn't work out --it can be a pain and inconvenience doing this but its allowed me to really discover and hone in on what works best for me. Hope this is helpful.
Steelcase Amia
Scammer. Get your money back with no remorse. Nothing else to this. If you’re in Ohio, I have a steelcase amia im gonna get rid of once I get my Aeron in. It’s squeaky a f tho.
Hi. I am also digital artist. I am also short. I also have back pain in lower left side. First I had a staples mesh chair which just made my back pain worse. I started to do a lot of research in standing desks and ergonomic chairs. I watched a lot of BTOD review videos on "best chair for short person," I'm 4'11 and the person was 5'2, which meant this person could still touch the floor with whatever chair they picked. But what I learned from those videos is that you have to go to the chair place and sit in the chairs to try them out. Some people like firm chairs,some people like soft chairs. We tested out steelcase chairs but they were too expensive. I liked the steelcase series 2 when I went to sit in it but not the price. I was able to find an office chair at a used office supply shop. I ended up with a weird/early model of the leap v1. It's been good for my back, but I do have a bit of neck pain now (probably from not moving around as much as I should). It's a firm chair, which might not work for everyone. My bf got the steelcase amia at discount which is too soft for me. I can touch the floor at the lowest setting. Very rare when you're as short as we are. My best advice is try out an office furniture store and see what fits you best. I got to sit in a Steelcase Gesture but I really couldn't see myself working in it for 8+ hours a day. They didn't have any herman millers I could try there. I don't think people take us vertically challenged people into account as much. We don't want kid stuff. And some stuff is designed with people who have longer spines. Also the fully desk I got goes down pretty low too to fit my height. It's been fine so far. Not an advertisement for these companies. Just saying my experience as someone on the shorter spectrum. Anyway, I hope this helped.
I started getting tailbone pain as soon as I started using a Steelcase Amia, so I bought an ergonomic pad. It kept hurting if I ever sat longer than 2 hours. I bought a HM Aeron, it was great for a day, then the tailbone pain came back. Then I read here you need adjust the height lower that you’d need expect, remove any of those ergonomic pads, and to give your body time to get used to it. Skipped the pad, lowered the chair. Stuck with it for 2 weeks. Pain is gone, love the freaking chair.
Steelcase Leap V2
i don't agree that this sub or reddit thinks "no other chair is even worth your time." i've seen consistent praise for the embody as well as steelcase leap v2s and gestures. no chair works for every body type. for me, the aeron is less comfortable than both the leap v2 and the embody.
stop buying gaming chairs, they're all the same foam and fake leather on a cheap frame. get an office chair instead, like something from steelcase or herman miller. i use a steelcase leap v2 for 5 years now and foam still good, no sinking, everything still tight. bought it used for like 400 bucks and it saw probably 10 years of office use before me, still solid
My work uses Steelcase Leap office chairs. I love them and had to have one of my own; found one on Facebook Marketplace for $100 or $120 years ago and snapped it up.
Steelcase Amia
Not a chair, but an adjustable standing desk saved my back. I have a steelcase amia chair I got from FB Marketplace (which is very comfortable and I would definitely recommend it), but standing a few hours a day is a real game changer for your back.
I got a refurbished Steelcase Amia recently and I like it so far. I work from home and am in it all day, no issues.
Sadly, no. It’s an event held by steelcase here in Grand Rapids once a year where they sell new to lightly used items for about 80% off. I got lucky to get this Amia chair, it was the last one. I originally went in hopes for a Leap V2 but the first people there got them. Leap chairs were $250 and Gestures were $300. Only downside is that they don’t come with warranty.