What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
SonosSonos Arc UltraReddit's pickReddit score
84% positive · 40 opinions
SamsungSamsung HW-Q990DReddit score
76% positive · 32 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Sound Quality
Value
Dialogue Clarity
App Setup
Vs Sonos
Software Bugs
Standalone Bass
Music Playback
Firmware Issues
Summary
Most owners are happy with the Sonos Arc Ultra, and many describe it as a pretty massive upgrade over the Arc. The biggest gain people point to is speech: there is a huge improvement on the voices, and buyers who tried several bars say the Arc Ultra setup sounds incredible, with a really nice wide soundstage. Setup in the app is usually smooth, with reports that everything went flawlessly.
Most owners of the Samsung HW-Q990D are very happy with it for movies and TV. People coming from older bars or TV speakers say it blows my other soundbars out of the water, describe extremely good overall sound quality, and call the main bar insanely rich and full sounding. Even people who gave up a full Klipsch/Denon system say they were completely blown away by the bar with its sub and wireless rears. One owner notes it sounded underwhelming at first because the soundbar has to calibrate itself to the room.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Sonos Arc Ultra
I called Sonos today, they told me There is a bug with the ultra and trueplay. The sound u get when using trueplay is not representing the arc ultra. They are working on a fix.
Arc Ultra + Era 100 surround performance: it is now pretty widely acknowledged that the Arc Ultra is playing surround channels itself rather than pushing to the rears, making the era 100s basically useless and the sound feel very forward heavy. There’s an active community forum discussion where Sonos reps have indicated this is a known issue. This is making me hugely regret my purchase and I’m coming up on the return window and really struggling to justify keeping this setup. When will this be fixed?
As a first soundbar owner as well, the Arc Ultra by itself didn’t blow me away. I too was hoping to get wowed by sounds coming from above and the sides. It wasn’t until I got a pair of Era 300s, did I hear the real Atmos experience.
Samsung HW-Q990D
Have just tried it for like 20 minutes but wow!! I don’t have any sub or surrounds yet, I will get the Era 300 tomorrow (wanted to see if I’m keeping this one first) Both the new dialog (booster) and the sound motion sounds absolutely amazing. I have tried the first arc but didn’t like the lack of center channel (dialog) but this one is a winner!! Also tried Bose Ultra soundbar(returned it) Samsung q990d (returned it) This one is stays!!
My Q990D bricked after the update. After contacted Sumsung (Thailand) they sent to guys for the repair. They already knew what was going on with the update and brought a box with a new pcb inside. No questions, they didn't try anything, they opened the soundbar and replaced the pcb! I was told to wait at least a month before trying to update and to turn off automatic updates. Took them 10 minutes, and the soundbar was properly working again.
No. Not at all. Check my impressions in this other post. www.reddit.com/r/Soundbars/comments/1ggj6gb/samsung\_q990d\_w\_sub\_and\_rear\_speakers\_vs\_sonos/ I too read the ratings reviews. Got the Samsung package. Wasn’t convinced about the sound. Got the Sonos. Returned the Samsung. Q990D/Q995D are a great value package. Great sound for the money with a lot of features like built in chromecast, a smarthings hub, dts-x support and HDMI ports. But they can’t achieve the level of performance of your system. Specially when it comes to music. Each individual component in your Sonos setup is superior to each component in the samsung package. The sub is in the Q995D get’s muddy at times. IT lacks detail. Overpowers other frequencies. Separation is better on the ultra. More detailed as well. The Era 300 are a lot and I mean a lot better than the surrounds on the Samsung package. That is in part why everything sounds so much better with the Sonos setup. If you are looking for a change or upgrade you need to go for options like Sony Bravia Theatre Quad and other higher end options. Your system already sounds better than the Samsung option and if you switch for sure you’ll get buyers remorse.
Sonos Arc Ultra
Have just tried it for like 20 minutes but wow!! I don’t have any sub or surrounds yet, I will get the Era 300 tomorrow (wanted to see if I’m keeping this one first) Both the new dialog (booster) and the sound motion sounds absolutely amazing. I have tried the first arc but didn’t like the lack of center channel (dialog) but this one is a winner!! Also tried Bose Ultra soundbar(returned it) Samsung q990d (returned it) This one is stays!!
preview.redd.it/0k9uw8csboxd1.jpeg?width=4080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a6ec7500b901e72532cecfd010443c223043100d Mine arrived about 30 min ago, replacing an existing arc. I bought the new wall mount and I can confirm it is smaller than the old arc wall mount, it was a painless swap just disconnected existing arc and mount put new mount on the wall and connected the new Arc Ultra using the existing cables. No issues with app adding the device either. My set up is 2xera 300 as rears with Arc now Arc Ultra and a gen3 Sub to the right of the Arc on the floor, my first thing I played on it was Avengers End Game(On your left scene) for those that care and wow the difference was immediate. I have had the old set up for a long time and i always liked it but i found voices/dialoged on the Arc to always leave me wanting, the first thing that was evident on the Ultra is huge improvement on the voices. I put normal terrestrial Tv on via my supplier SKY tv and normally i have to have volume at around 15 with voice boost on for it to be clear, with the ultra its at 10 and no voice boost and crystal clear. Will give updated review tonight as I have the UHD Twister sitting to be watched and starting the Dark Night Trilogy. All in all first impressions are great.
Wish I could upvote this post 100 times. The music capabilities of the 300s with the front driver and without are night and day. I’m extremely happy with my arc ultra and 300s as surrounds for movies/tv, but after hearing the 300s in stereo mode it has completely ruined the music experience for me with them paired as surrounds. All I want is to be able to hear music from the front driver. For the price I don’t think it’s unreasonable to at least hope we’d be able to use the full capability of the speaker for music without sacrificing them as surrounds.
Samsung HW-Q990D
I’ve had Sony, lg, and Vizio and recently got a q990d and it blows my other soundbars out of the water. There are definitely better surround sound options out there. But as far as soundbars go it seems it’s either Sonos or Samsung that most people champion. And most reviewers agree.
I have the q990d. For the price point I got it at around (900usd) when it was initially released. It's worth every penny. Easy setup hardware and software. Extremely good overall sound quality. I am happy with the bass(I am not a bass person). The sound details are amazing at times. Great clarity. Me and a few friends sometimes get confused as to if the sound is from the audio or is it from somewhere nearby. E.g. a phone ringing has been confused as someone's phone was actually ringing.
Yes. By a good margin. .... That said.... I recently traded out my speakers/amp setup and the while the sound is not as good, the ease of use has been more than worth the trade. The soundbar sounds pretty darn good in its own right and more than does the trick for watching movies/TV or playing video games. (Samsung Q990D) That said.... The soundbar is awful for music. It's so bad, that I ended up hooking up my record player to some Audioengine HD3 (w/sub) that I had in my bedroom and the sound was significantly better than what was coming from the Soundbar. TLDR; Speakers = Better Sound all around but more cumbersome. Soundbar = Terrible for music but good for everything else AND generally the system is just easier to use.