What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
RecteqRecteq Flagship 1600Reddit score
100% positive · 72 opinions
WeberWeber Searwood 600Reddit score
100% positive · 58 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Too close to call
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Too close to call
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Build Quality
Searing
Accessories
Temperature Control
Smoke Flavor
Temp Stability
Customer Support
Easy Cleaning
Value
App
Summary
Owners of the Recteq Flagship 1600 and its Flagship siblings are strongly positive, especially about build quality. They describe VERY heavy gauge construction, say fit and finish is excellent, and owners of the older RT-1250 found the hardware in another league compared with Traegers at big box stores. The rear-mounted hopper means less chance of jams.
The Weber Searwood 600 gets consistently strong reviews, mostly for doing both smoking and grilling. Owners report less than 12 minutes 0 - 600 degrees and say it sears as well as the Weber Summit it replaced; others say I haven’t touched my charcoal kettle in a year. With the griddle insert and rotisserie, one owner calls it one grill replacing 3, and many buy it for the accessory ecosystem.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Weber Searwood 600
No complaints found on Reddit yet.
Recteq Flagship 1600
I never trusted my Pit Boss for overnight cooks. Heck sometimes I didn't trust it when I was sitting there staring at it. I've done them several times with my Flagship 1100 and never had a problem (little over a year old). I honestly don't think I'll ever use any pellet smoker other than Recteq at this point. I've only needed their support twice, and both times they were fantastic.
I've heard so many mixed things about Traeger I also decided against them. My research led me to Recteq. They seem to offer the best build quality, reliability, performance and customer service for the price. After assembling my RT-1250 a year ago and comparing the hardware against the traegers I've seen at big box stores it's clear Recteq is in another league. The RT-1250 is a bit out of your price range but RT-590 is pretty close and if you're willing to stretch your budget a little further there's the RT-700
I won’t bother with anything other than a RecTeq. Their customer service is awesome and their builds are great quality. Currently own an RT700, 380 Bullseye, and a Flagshit 1100.
Weber Searwood 600
I have both pellet and charcoal. I have used charcoal for most of my cooking life, I have used pellets for about 4-5 years. Pellets are alot more convenient for sure. The smoke taste isn't as strong as with wood/charcoal, but I don't find it to be overly drastic. All pellet cookers have a "smoke mode" that you can activate to get some smoke on your meat, which helps, but it won't reach the levels of a charcoal/wood combo. You are sacrificing that for the convenience factor. I have a Weber Searwood. It can smoke and sear very well and cleanup is very easy/quick.
Weber Smokefire has been replaced with the Searwood. I have a Searwood XL and it’s done everything I’ve wanted it to do very well and I haven’t had one issue with it.
I have the Weber Searwood and couldn't be happier, gives a nice smoke flavour. I also looked at the Masterbuilt but the design and quality of the components made me decided to go for Weber.