What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
PelotonPeloton TreadReddit's pickReddit score
74% positive · 43 opinions
SoleSole F80Reddit score
60% positive · 81 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Reliability
Customer Service
Apps & Screen
Classes
Noise
Cost
Running Feel
Weight Capacity
Repairability
Screen Shake
Summary
Most owners of the Peloton Tread are happy with it, and many have put heavy mileage on it for years. One runner averaging around 60 miles a week since 2020 has never had to fix or replace anything, and owners coming from other brands note they have gone for 3 years and not one squeak. The jump buttons and dials get frequent praise because the speed increases and decreases very quickly, which makes HIIT-style classes practical, and one marathoner was surprised the belted deck felt as good as it does without a motor plate cutting into the stride. The content is the main draw: owners who used to avoid treadmills say the classes fly by, and features like Lanebreak and the new ReRuns feature is awesome keep indoor runs varied.
Owners of the Sole F80 most often describe it as a sturdy, no-nonsense home treadmill. Several report long, trouble-free use, from 3k+ miles with normal maintenance to older units that ran for a decade or more, and one sums it up as a great no-frills solid consumer-grade treadmill. It feels like an overall sturdier machine than rivals some buyers came from, and heavier runners chose it because they wanted something that could take regular jogging. Some find it super quiet for getting the runs in, and buyers like that there are tons of free programs with no subscription required, plus Bluetooth that syncs seamlessly with my Peloton app and other third-party apps.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Peloton Tread
I don’t even remember being offered an extended warranty by them, but to be fair, I likely would’ve waived it off. That’s my standard operating policy. The thought of a third party extended warranty never crossed my mind, I will remember that for next time. And to answer the final question, I paid with a debit card, so no extended warranty through them. On the bright side, Reddit analytics tells me that this is the #1 viewed post on Reddit Treadmills today. So I hope I’ve caused at least one person to avoid buying a peloton treadmill, just so I can point out how shortsighted it was for Peloton to give me such trash customer service. Good customer service would have saved them thousands of $.
I hope you’re successful! Peloton kept replacing mine. I sold the last replacement before even using it to get out of the cycle. The new owners had a warranty claim within the first year. Not sure why the issue is, maybe they fixed on the new model? Regardless, I bought a Wahoo Kickr Run and never looked back. A shame, I love the Peloton classes.
No both sides are connected as one giant unit. That’s why even when changing the belt you need to slide the entire walking deck out the back. It’s very difficult design for self maintenance. This is why when there are any deck/belt issues Peloton just recommends you buy an entire bottom of the unit (belt, deck, motor) although they charge $1200+ for that.
Sole F80
I have an F80 as well. The motor control board has been replaced twice, the motor replaced once, and the incline motor is now going to be replaced. I bought it six months ago, and have barely used it - not much indoor running for me in the summer. In total, less than an hour's use on it. It has failed every time I've gone to use it (4x) then I get to wait a few weeks to get a part and a tech. Wish I had selected another model or brand.
I have the 2022 version of the F80 purchased new in 2023. It will take your weight fine and has lots of track room. Be prepared to keep the deck oiled and the belt properly tensioned, as soon as you sense any feeling of drag as this puts added strain on the motor controller leading to burn out. Mine did not last (2800 miles) even with care due to my running for 1.5 to 2hrs at a time, which is something Sole told me it is not really designed to do. They did send me a new controller board under warranty and I am moving to a commercial unit, more suited to my needs. Also be prepared to buy a new belt (not that expensive), even if the top surface looks pristine. The belt backing can get rougher leading to more friction even with an oiled deck. I miss the old system of waxing decks, I got 16000 miles out of my last treadmill (BodyGuard T460X) and 12000 miles from the original belt.
I have a sole f80, sux, total crap in my experience. Im getting ready order a 3g. I emailed and asked them questions, they got back to me the same day and their warranty and customer service seems very good. I wouldn't do Nordic trac just based on the amount of negative reviews I've seen, however I have never owned one either.
Peloton Tread
I got a peloton tread in 2020 right when covid lockdown started and have put a shit ton of miles on it (60mpw average with an even mix indoors and outside). I’ve never had to fix or replace anything. My biggest complaint is that the incline only goes to 12.5%.
I got one of the first Peloton Treads to land in North America when it launched and I have not had one single issue in the 3 years I've had it and I run on it 6 to 7 hours per week. It is the first and only treadmill I have ever owned that has required little to no maintenance. (I owned 3 treadmills prior to this one and had to get them serviced 2 to 3 times per year because of squeaks. There is still not one squeak from this thing 3 years later. It's the favorite thing I have ever purchased, and I have had no issues with the screen shaking at any speed. Glad you are happy withyour Kickr, they look awesome.
If you already have the peloton bike then get the peloton tread. Especially if you love using the bike. You will be using the same interface and won’t have to get a separate membership for classes if you got the Nordic. Plus the basic tread and Nordic tread are basically the same price I have both bike and tread from peloton and love it.
Sole F80
I bought a treadmill back in December, and did a decent amount of research and concluded that Costco doesn't have any treadmills that are worth it. I ended up getting a Sole f80 from Dick's sporting goods, which has been great so far. I would recommend checking out r/treadmills
I had the same goal as you when I initially went treadmill shopping. I couldn't really justify to myself spending more than $500 on a treadmill, but still wanted something good quality. Unfortunately I soon realized the same thing that everyone else in our shoes also realized - it doesn't exist. I would say the *minimum* price for a treadmill that isn't a total pile of hot garbage starts at around $1000. Check out the Sole F63, they have it at Dick's Sporting Goods right now for $999. I don't think you're realistically going to find anything of acceptable quality for any less than that. I personally ended up moving my budget up higher than I really wanted to, and got a Sole F80 for around $1700 (because I wanted the more powerful motor and wider deck). Was more than I wanted to spend, but it's been a fantastic treadmill and I'm very happy with it. A used treadmill is always an option, but then you're not really going to have much warranty (if any) and there's always the mystery of what might be wrong with it and what it would take to fix it, which is a hassle I'm just not willing to deal with to save a couple hundred bucks, personally. If you need to have an expert come out and work on it even just once, then that wipes out all the money you saved and then some. You said you're putting it in your garage - make sure it's not too cold (or hot) and damp in there. Indoors is preferred, but it can work in a garage as long as the temp and moisture don't get too crazy in there. Another option is just buy a $500 cheapo treadmill from Amazon or whatever, knowing that it's kind of a piece of junk and won't last that long but at least you won't have to worry as much about it getting wrecked keeping it out in your garage.
Sole f80 with 3k+ miles with normal maintenance. No issues and would buy another sole if it messed up. I just use it as a treadmill though. I don’t use any of the tech on it. I use my phone for that.