What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
OoniOoni Karu 12Reddit score
90% positive · 58 opinions
OoniOoni Koda 16Reddit score
89% positive · 62 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Too close to call
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Too close to call
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Fuel Options
Learning Curve
Pizza Size
Heat Up
Durability
L-Shaped Burner
Gas Convenience
Versatility
NY Style
Summary
The Ooni Karu 12 is well liked by most owners, many of whom simply say I have one and love it. Its multi-fuel design is the main draw, since you can make pizzas with wood and gas, and it gets hot quickly: owners report reaching 450C in around 20-30 minutes with wood and one cranked out 8 12 inch pizzas in just over 30 minutes. People also cook steaks, flatbreads and camp breakfasts in it, and one calls it the star of the camp show.
The Ooni Koda 16 is a well-liked gas pizza oven, and many owners echo you really can’t go wrong with the Koda 16. The most common praise is convenience: it just works everytime, no need to mess with wood, with about A 30-min preheat at full tilt and no problem reaching 900F. Many credit the burner layout (the L shaped burner is a game changer). Owners also report it holds up outdoors for years: My old koda 16 is indestructible, and even rusty units still makes pizza just fine.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Ooni Karu 12
Eh. 25-35 min until it’s at temp for me. I went from the Ooni Karu 12 to this so I never used any comparable Ooni like the Koda. My overall impression is that Gozney makes a better quality oven in general though.
What’s made the biggest difference/improvement? I just got a Karu 12 and have wanted to rage quit both times I’ve cooked with it so far haha.
I had the exact same happen with my Karu 12 within a year of ownership. Used a few times outside and then stored in a dry garage in its bag before discovered on unwrapping it. I have kept the inside sooty moving forward as the last person I showed it to wasn't super keen on eating the pizza after having seen inside! Ooni customer services were pretty dismissive and said it is expected for the product if it's left outside or in a garage for a sustained period of time. I was told the rust wouldn't impact the end result and to be fair to them, it doesn't seem to have done. It just doesn't look very good and honestly, is not what I expected from such a premium product.
Ooni Koda 16
Here are four pizzas that demonstrate the 1-year progression of my NY-style pizza making journey! As you can see, the end product has come a long way, and I feel like I’m finally at the point where I can say that I make a pretty decent NY-style pie. It isn’t on the level of the best pizzas that I used to get when I lived in Manhattan, but it beats anything I can get delivered to my house here in suburban Massachusetts. Best of all, it’s easy as hell to make! Once you’ve ironed out the details and refined your process, it really is a low-effort meal. Over the summer I got an Ooni Koda 16 oven, but ultimately I’ve realized that I achieve more consistent results in my home oven for this style. Here is my recipe/process: Dough: - 400g bread flour (I use King Arthur’s) - 1 tsp diastatic malt powder (King Arthur’s) - 12g salt - 6g sugar - 2g instant dry yeast - 1 tbs extra virgin olive oil - 8oz water - semolina flour for working surface Sauce: - 28oz whole peeled tomatoes (I use Bianco DiNapoli) - salt to taste - sugar to taste (use very sparingly; the sauce shouldn’t read as sweet) - 1 tsp dried oregano - 2-3 leaves of fresh basil - 1 clove of garlic, finely diced Cheese: - 50/50 blend of low moisture whole milk mozzarella and low moisture part skim mozzarella (I use what’s available, but often Galbani) - pecorino romano (I use block Locatelli) Process: 3 days before serving pizza: 1. Combine flour, water, and olive oil in a large bowl with a spoon. Form into a ball, leave in bowl, cover in plastic wrap, and let sit for 20 minutes. 2. Add salt, sugar, yeast, and diastatic malt powder (easiest to do this while kneading on a large flat surface). Knead until well-combined. Form into a ball, leave in bowl, cover in plastic wrap, and let sit for 20 additional minutes. 3. Knead dough ball until it passes the windowpane test (this takes less than 5 minutes for me). Form into a ball, pinch off seam in one spot, place into bowl (seam-side down), cover in plastic wrap, and let sit for 2 hours at room temperature. 4. After 2 hours, move bowl to refrigerator and leave for 72 hours. Day of serving pizza: 1. Remove bowl from refrigerator and leave at room temperature for 2 hours before cooking. At the same time, preheat oven with pizza steel to 550F. 2. For sauce: combine tomatoes, oregano, basil, and garlic, and blend until there are no large tomato chunks left (this goes very quickly with my immersion blender; do not over-blend). Add salt and sugar to taste (again, sugar should be used sparingly, and you may not even need it depending on your tomatoes). 3. For cheese: grate mozzarella into a container and then put it back into the fridge until ready to use. Pizza assembly: 1. Once the oven is ready (I let my oven sit at temperature for at least 30 minutes to ensure steel is very hot), dust your dough-working surface with semolina flour. Carefully remove dough ball from bowl. The top of the ball (side opposite of seam) will be the bottom of your pizza. Place that side down onto the semolina, then dust the top of dough ball (seam side) with more semolina. 2. Use your fingers to press out the dough into a disc, taking care to not make the middle too thin. Pick up dough and stretch it with your hands (watch videos of this process) until desired size is reached. Place dough onto a steel pizza screen and then make any adjustments needed to ensure it is the right size and shape. 3. Add sauce (less than you’d think) to center of dough and spread outwards, leaving a very thin (thinner than you’d think) crust at the edge of pizza. 4. Grate a thin layer of pecorino romano cheese over sauce. 5. Evenly distribute mozzarella (less than you’d think) over sauce. Cooking the pizza: 1. Turn off oven. Turn broiler on high. After 5 minutes, place screen + pizza directly onto pizza steel. 2. After 3 minutes, carefully remove screen out from under the pizza and place pizza directly onto steel. 3. Pizza is done when the cheese and crust start to lightly brown. Remove pizza before the cheese starts to break, and check the bottom of the pizza to ensure it isn’t burning.
I've run into the same problem with the Koda 16. I've done the following: \- Make sure the stone is 800+ degrees F prior to launching \- Launch and then shut off the flame altogether, just let the stone cook the bottom of the pizza \- After a minute or so, relight the flame to medium and start rotating the pizza fairly regularly until reaching your desired level of doneness on the top \- Turn the flame up to max to get the stone hot again for the next pizza
In this post is the pizza I made on the Ooni Koda 16. The pizza made in the home oven with steel is posted here. Same dough recipe. Same toppings. Very similar results. A couple of caveats: 1.) This isn’t a fair fight. The Ooni is designed to deliver ultra high temps and 60-90 second bakes. It’s killer for Neapolitan style pizzas. It is not designed for NY style, & 2.) I have WAY more experience cooking NY style in my home oven on steel, so while I know the quirks, when I move to the Ooni, I’m still learning. That said: Home oven on steel is still the winner for me with this style. The Ooni required near constant attending and the bottom crust never really got there. It’s good pizza, but way too soft to be considered NY style. It’s more like a chain delivery pizza. Cooked, but missing the crisp I was looking for. If you click into the other post, you can see just how dramatic the difference is on the underside. You can also see the crust browning is less consistent. The Ooni Koda 16 burners are “L” shaped, so the back corner is hotter and hits harder straight away, affecting both the spring and the browning. Lots of turning. It barely fit a 16” shell, too, so the pizza is really close to the flame. Still, it’s a good pizza and cooking outdoors is a great option if it’s hot out and you don’t want to run the oven inside, or if your camping and just gotta have pizza.
Ooni Karu 12
I treated myself an Ooni Karu 12 in the Black Friday sale after a long time thinking about getting one and finally get my teeth into making homemade wood fired pizzas 🍕 ! Well that thing has finally been unboxed and assembled… Looks really well made too… All stainless steel! I also got in the sale a long handed turning peel and a wire brish to clean the stone… my old little folding camping table has earned itself another use too! We got the oven, got the right 00 flour and yeast… we got the tomato sauce, the mozzarella and all the toppings… all things going to plan so far we’re having wood fired 🔥 pizza 🍕! … or so I thought! Haha 😂 I was like a kid on Christmas day! I used the Ooni napolitana dough recipe (500g of flour, 300ml of water, 10g of salt, 3.5g of instant yeast) but instead of all white flour I used 420g of white flour and 80g of wholemeal flour and I also added to the recipe a teaspoon of runny honey… unfortunately I think I overproofed the dough for too long! It was a complete disaster 😂🤣😂🤦♀️ The dough stuck to the peel like mad and just wouldn’t get off it, but being the stubborn mare that I am, I still attempted to get the pizzas into the oven… big mistake, the pizzas collapsed in themselves as i tried yanking them off the peel and half the toppings ended up on the stone! 😭 i think the problem was partly the overproofing of the dough leading to the dough tearing off holes in the middle as i was stretching it and not enough flour on the worktop and peel to avoid it sticking… To top it all off, I even forgot the first pizza while preparing the second pizza and it burned to a crisp and even caught fire 🔥 inside the oven leaving a huge mess on the stone and the pizza a sorry charred lump! The oven works fantastic but the dough and my technique wasn’t right… it was infuriating but at the same time I took it as a major learning opportunity and I have been dissecting all the things I did wrong and how to course correct next time! In the end we ended up ordering takeout pizza 🍕 for delivery 😂! Hopefully my next pizza attempt on the Karu 12 will go much smoother and I’ll have something worthwhile to share and post.
I recommend Vito Iacopelli's recipes on youtube. His channel is a bit all over the place with a lot of different dough recipes, but his recipes, advice and techniques are absolutely solid. This is the one I'd recommend youtu.be/u7Hd6ZzKgBM (I've tried several). I'm not sure how new you are to pizza making in general, but my main recommendation actually would be learning how to handle the dough. Pretty much any Neapolitan dough recipe will give you nice results if you handle the dough well. I've seen friends make good dough and then make mistakes like roll it out flat with a rolling pin, use tons of flour on the peel, etc. Results of course were disappointing. So, how to ball the dough without breaking the surface, how to stretch the dough, how much semola to use, how much topping is enough or too much, how to launch, how to turn, etc. Congrats on your Karu 12! I have one and love it
I regularly make Nhan and Pita in my Ooni! Absolutely delicious. You’ll have to experiment through trial and error on the correct temp. I cook with wood and coal; I preheat for a pizza cook and then let the fire die back significantly so it’s not “rolling” over the top of the oven. I use a pizza peal to slide into the oven. Bread will puff up, and you need to be vigilant that it’s not too close the heat. I can usually fit 2 sometimes 3 in my Karu 12. Unrelated: Not sure if oriental is the appropriate word anymore. I thought it had a racist/demeaning origin.
Ooni Koda 16
$700 is a great price for what it is. i got my ooni koda 16 for $300 a couple of years ago.
Ooni Koda 16, I turned it on at 230 and shut it off around 8pm, about 30 minutes warm up, and 30 minutes burn down.
Info on the pizza: * Mulino caputo flour. Used a mix of 30% Nuvola : 70% pizzeria (always like using a mix of Nuvola and Pizzeria but I only had enough to do 30% Nuvola left in my bag hence the seemingly random ratio!) * 63% hydration * 24hr RT proof (22hr bulk, 2hr ball) * San Marzano tomatoes * Fior di latte mozarella + pecorino * Pepperoni (properoni) + cheeky salami slice or two Cooked on an ooni koda 16. Been using it every week since I got one just before Christmas and think I've got it down the last few weeks. I'm kdjpizza on Instagram if anyone cares (not sure if self promo is allowed, happy to delete if mods get in touch)