What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
NeakasaNeakasa M1 PlusReddit score
87% positive · 130 opinions
WhiskerWhisker Litter-Robot 4Reddit score
83% positive · 424 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Too close to call
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Convenience
Reliability
Safety
Odor Control
Value
Open Top
Size
Easy Cleaning
Litter Scatter
Summary
The Neakasa M1 Plus, like the original M1 it replaced, is liked mostly for its open-top drum. Many owners who switched from enclosed boxes say their cats seemed to like the open top more, and it is a common pick for big cats, described as Open top great for large or picky cats; several Maine Coon owners report He has enough space. Cleaning is the other big draw: owners call it super duper simple to clean because the dome lifts off in one piece. Safety comes up often too, with people noting the open top design never fully closes, and the app gets credit for health tracking because it automatically logs their usage data. A good number of long-term owners say it has performed flawlessly for the 6 months or more.
The Litter-Robot 4 is most often praised for taking the daily chore out of cat care. Owners describe trading scooping for the chance to just take out a bag once every couple of weeks, and multi-cat households often run one unit for several cats (all three of my cats use without issue). Routine upkeep is described as quick, often something that takes no more than 5 minutes a week, and the optional Litter Hopper gets frequent recommendations (I HIGHLY recommend getting a hopper). Odor control is a common highlight, with one owner noting that guests openly commented what happened to the smell, and the unit is repeatedly called quiet (insanely quiet and works good). Per-cat weight tracking has helped some owners spot health problems early, such as when we caught a downward trend in weight.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Neakasa M1 Plus
Haven’t tried it, but I did have the Neakasa M1 as a second. I sold it and got another LR4. You can’t beat the overall quality/features of the LR4 with how quiet it is, odor control, and convinces like the litter hopper and globe lights.
I don’t have it anymore (unfortunately bc my guys abs hate the self cleaning noises/movements) but I really loved the Meowant SC02! It wasn’t perfect, but I found it much more user friendly and less buggy than my Litter Robot 4, PETKIT PuraMax 2 and Neakasa M1. I went through a lot of trial and error before just settling back on a manual box. Beautiful babies and what an awesome set up!! Living their best life!
Petlibro Luma vs Litter-Robot 5 for long-term?
I bought the Neakasa M1 a month before the Luna was announced and I was blowed! I couldn’t scoop anymore, had been watching the Neakasa for a year or so so I took the leap, because it has a large space for my male cat. Then thy dropped the Luma and I was like wtf nooooo cause I own everything else Petlibro. With my Neakasa it’s only grown more annoying overtime, but I still don’t have to scoop anymore. My cat LOVES to bury his duty no matter what so not all of it “scoops” out technically. About every 3-5 days I have to take it apart, flip it, and wipe the sensors with acetone because they get covered in a white substance somehow which makes the bottom read as full and it’s not even close to full. When I deep clean I legit have to take the entire thing apart and sock the rubber pad since my male cat buries his duty and some of it gets left behind under the good litter. My cats didn’t like the litter catch step up at first. One of them likes to jump out too which send litter flinging all over the place. I plan to get the new air filter step thing for it, as the aroma of the poop and urine does seep out near it, Contact Neakasa and they just want to troubleshoot, they don’t wanna actually help for the price tag you’ll pay for the sucker. It still works, works well! Don’t fill it 100% with litter where it says cause you’ll lose perfectly good litter. I actually did this and then ran the clean to see how much I would lose and it was sooo much bro. You learn. I can tell sometimes the cats feel weird going like “in the open”. I plan to get the Luma either way. It looks a bit narrower which means my male cat would need to tun around and put his bum to the backside to go. And I need to compete my collection. I have the Scout Camera, the RFID water fountain, and two RFID feeders. I need Luma and the auto wet feeders. My cats picked up to all of the devices semi quickly. My male cat learned he’ll never get his feeder to open if he takes his collar off so he’s grown out of that. I also save money on cat food this way. My 8 year old female is on a different food than my 4 year old male. He was hogging the shared auto Catit Feeder with every drop. He doesnt do that anymore. Better food, better feeder that tracks how much and how long they go through a bag on their own. They are like “Ant proof” in a sense. So the ants definitely found and moved with the feeders as I moved them around to avoid the ants. Eventually they figured out id win lol. But the ants never once go into the actual chambers where the food is stored. They would be all around the seals and try to go up the feeder drop hole, but never could. Both of my feeders stopped notifying me a at low food levels, and after a bad ant day I had to take my male cats feeder apart entirely and direct those silly ants out. Put it back together and it reads low food levels again. I read some posts prior saying it’s the sensor pad that gives out, however deep cleaning 1/2 of mine showed me that is a potential fix for the low food level sensor issue. Now, Petlibro did me dirty and turned around and released most products in the black tone 😑 after I invested into the traditional colors, as they were the only ones available. I plan to get everything in the black again even though I have the white. Definitely more info than you asked for but I like Petlibro if you couldn’t tell lol. I can’t justify a LR for any price tbh cause I’m extra and want the newest biggest baddest tech always dropped lol. My male cat, I also adopted (rehomed) from a household that actively used a litter robot and he didn’t adjust well coming to a traditional box at the time. He wanted the litter fresh and clean for every last duty he would take and if it wasn’t he would just poo right next to the box. Yea he and I didn’t get along well those days…now we are on good terms lol. Once I added the Neakasa to our picture probably 1.5 to 2 years later after brining him home, he took right back to it. My female cat was a bit skeptical at first. She didn’t understand but she took to it just fine. I don’t have any small cats or kittens so I can’t attest for the sensors not working for smaller sized kitties. I know there’s a horror story out there about one being crushed with the Neaksa, but they have since fixed the issue and added a 6th sensor for the M1 Plus model. I don’t think the little add on lip for it, or wall-whatever you wanna call that little piece you can buy, is worth it since my male cat jumps out flinging litter. Maybe with the litter robot steps he would not do that. Honestly will never not have an auto box again. My kitties are smart! Like I said I’m getting the Luma either way lol.
Whisker Litter-Robot 4
STAINLESS STEEL LITTERBOX FTW Way better than my litter robot 4.0
I've tried several automatic litter boxes. Most offer 30/60/90-day trial periods with free returns, which I highly recommend taking advantage of. My first attempt was the Litter Robot 4. Unfortunately, it arrived damaged (the back part wasn't fully attached and the rotation mechanism worked improperly). They sent a replacement, but it appeared to be a returned item with scratches and different packaging. It was also glitchy, so considering the high price tag, I returned it. Next, I tried Leo's Loo Too. While well-built overall, it lacked a proper step for my cat and had a tight interior that created extra mess. My cat would touch the walls inside, ending up dusty after each use. Another return. The PetSafe model had issues similar to Leo's Loo Too. It was designed too high, causing mess whenever my cat jumped out. It was even smaller inside, resulting in my cat occasionally peeing outside the designated area. This experience made me decide against trying Catlink or similar models. After several disappointments, I searched for a litter box with a low entrance and larger interior space. The PetSnowy model finally worked for both me and my cat. In my opinion, it's best engineered for larger cats and cats in general. I've had it for over a year with no glitches or mess, and my cat is comfortable using it. If PetSnowy hadn't worked out, my last resort would have been Lavviebot, though its price tag is significantly higher.
unfortunately not. hoping the option to correct incorrect cat identification and weights will come soon. allow us to help the smartscale algorithm! especially since we can actually see who is using the box rather that the robot guessing based on weight. prior to the LR4, my petkit boxes (X and MAX) allowed you to correct wrong weight readings!
Neakasa M1 Plus
There is a Youtuber called "One Man. Five Cats," who reviews automatic litter boxes. He's also the guy that made the video informing other of the dangers of the knock-off litter boxes. Thanks to him, I went for a mid-priced box, Neakasa M1, and we've had no problems with it. Makes clean up so much easier. Which Are The BEST Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes? The DEADLY Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes That Have Flooded The Market
I have 4 cats and two Neakasa M1 Automatic litter boxes. They have made my life so much easier, especially now that I'm pregnant. I only need to empty once a week and it's super easy to deep clean when needed. The Neaskas is one of the few open top automatic litter boxes so my cats took to it quickly. Neakasa litterboxes are not one of the litterboxes killing cats. The Neakasa along with Litter Robots are very safe. .
The danger varies by design, I have an open top robot litter box which is a bit safer (also way easier to take apart to clean). You can also turn off the automatic function and set it to only run when you push the button/trigger it in the app (we do this because I’m paranoid). The established brands generally have multiple redundancies built in to trigger the cleaning cycle to stop if they sense a cat is in it or nearby, but a lot of the cheaper ones don’t and those are the ones that have seen pet deaths. They don’t recommend having the auto clean functionality on if you have a kitten or small cat under a certain weight as they’re harder for the machine to sense too. Ours has been worth it 100x over even without having the auto mode on because both of our cats have had toileting related health issues this year (constipation and bloody urine) which we’ve been able to track as our litter box (we have the Neakasa M1) automatically logs their usage data. It allowed us to figure out that it was our ‘healthy’ cat that had blood in her urine, without it we would have assumed it was our 14 year old cat because he’s always the one with the health problems. Our vet is a big fan too as the data was handy for him!
Whisker Litter-Robot 4
I have a fancy Litter Robot 4 that is amazing.. with 3 cats would I need to keep an additional litter box set up? I’m fine with that. Just thinking about logistics.
The reputable ones are extremely safe and very nice. Why scoop 3x a day when you could just take out a bag once every couple of weeks? I have a litter robot (same as the one in this post) and it's amazing.
I have a single Litter Robot 4 that all three of my cats use without issue. Be careful about letting it run automatically if the kittens are still small, though. This is the official recommendation from their website: "Litter-Robot 4 uses laser and weight sensor technology to detect when your cat enters and exits the globe, which triggers the countdown timer and cleaning cycle. The SmartScale® will not recognize kittens that weigh less than 3 lbs. Therefore, kittens that weigh less than 3 lbs can use Litter-Robot 4, but not in automatic mode. Until they weigh enough, we recommend using your Litter-Robot in "semi-automatic" mode to keep your kitten safe and relieve you from litter box scooping. For "semi-automatic" mode, leave Litter-Robot powered off or unplugged. When you see your kitten has used it, wait about 7 minutes for the waste to clump, then power it on. Litter-Robot will automatically perform a clean cycle. Afterward, power it off again. Continue this supervised, semi-automatic mode until your kittens have gained sufficient weight to activate the SmartScale®."