What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
MilwaukeeMilwaukee M18 FUEL 21-inch Self-PropelledReddit's pickReddit score
89% positive · 99 opinions
GreenworksGreenworks 60V 21-inch Self-PropelledReddit score
89% positive · 35 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Too close to call
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Battery Life
Cutting Power
Reliability
Battery Ecosystem
Price
Cut Quality
Bagging
Quietness
Build Quality
Warranty Support
Summary
Owners mostly praise the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 21-inch self-propelled mower for its cutting power. Several say thick or overgrown grass doesn't slow it down: one says I could not stall it, and another says it cuts 14 inch grass like it's nothing. People who switched from Ego, DeWalt, Ryobi or Greenworks battery mowers say the Milwaukee has more grunt. Owners also like the heavy build, since it has an actual steel deck, and they say it's plenty of power, quiet. Other features people mention are the variable thumb throttle, the headlights for mowing at dusk, being able to store the mower upright, and no longer having to worry about gas or engine maintenance.
The Greenworks 60V 21-inch self-propelled mower gets mostly positive reports from long-term owners. Many describe years of trouble-free use, such as had it for 6 years and no issues or it never lets me down 4 years running, and one 2019 buyer says the pro series is a tank. Owners like that it is quieter, lighter, cleaner than gas, with very little vibration in the handles, a steel deck, good power and a handle that folds for vertical storage. One owner who later switched to EGO still felt the Greenworks was the better mower, and another prefers it because like the Greenworks better because of the side shoot.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 21-inch Self-Propelled
Hi, the mulching blade actually had less lift than the standard blade. Maybe your grass type is better suited for this mower, but for St. Augustine at max height, it definitely isn’t, unless Milwaukee releases a true high-lift blade. St Augustine grass is very thick.
I think it's mostly because of the price. I tried it out when it first came out, so not with the forge batteries, and the price premium was definitely not worth it. I ended up sticking with a Ryobi 40v because at the time I could buy 2 Ryobi mower kits for the price of one Milwaukee kit and the performance was very similar. I haven't tried the newest model so I can't say if I'd still make the same decision but my Ryobi hasn't failed yet so there's been no need for me to reenter that market yet.
I had same issue and brought it to the local milwaukee repair place. The metal lock washer melted to the old plastic spacer, it stops the sugar from spinning. I thought i broke the sugar if the motor when I took the old blade off. FYI buying a new blade from a place like home depot you just get the blade and plastic washer, from a real milwaukee service center for and price you get that, the metal lock wallet thing, the big round plastic housing with vents and the metal collar shat cover. The internet was no help fixing this, I was like crap I need to get a new mower.
Greenworks 60V 21-inch Self-Propelled
Got a greenworks 60V, changed the blades and sharpened them twice before I realized it was just a suction issue. You’re 100% right
I have noticed uneven cut from time to time with my Greenworks 60v too with bumpy terrain or high or thicker grass. Like OP, I stopped self propel and walked slower, and especially in my front yard I manually turned on turbo to increase blade speed and the cut evened out even on a standard blade. I believe Ego has a lever to fine tune blade speed adjustment even more so than GW, so I’d crank it to the max OP at least over thick grass, and hopefully it evens out the cut. Ego is a very highly rated mower for battery - maybe go ask your question on the Ego sub and see if they have any suggestions.
I have greenworks 60v and my first battery is beginning to fail right around the 5 year mark. I see someone else mentioned getting 8 years but I wasn’t that lucky. FWIW it has always been stored indoors except for when it was being used.
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 21-inch Self-Propelled
You don’t have to worry about gas or engine maintenance. I have the Milwaukee mower and I have several large batteries so i basically have unlimited range on the thing. It cuts as well or better than the equivalent Toro gas mower that it replaced. It’s a little quieter and easier to run because you can stop and start it with the press of a button. Not having to winterize it is another perk. The only situation where gas is superior is if you have a huge yard and don’t want to worry about swapping out multiple sets of batteries.
My Honda mower died after 15 years and i bought the Milwaukee off eBay for $587 ( recondition) sold the two 12ah & charger and kept the mower for $200 and it's awesome. I have about a 1/4 acre and two 6ah is more than enough.
Mower is amazing, but expensive. I’m going in to my third full season with it without issue. I sold off my Honda after a year because I just didn’t use it anymore, and the Milwaukee is so similar ergonomically to it that I felt right at home.
Greenworks 60V 21-inch Self-Propelled
I love how quiet my electric mower is and also very little vibration in the handles. I use greenworks 60v. I’ve found that you MUST keep your blade sharp to have good battery life.
$1000 is a great budget. I’ve got a Greenworks 60v pro walk behind, and Bermuda. Easily adjustable height, steel deck, good power. I have had it for 4.5 years now and love that it needs zero oil, zero gas, zero maintenance outside of a blade sharpen and deck cleaning. Also never had to fight a choke, or a pull cord. Push button life.
Bought 60v greenworks in 2019. Then got every other piece of lawn equipment from them. One 5ag and four 2ah batteries. 1/2 acre lot. I don't really have any complaints except the auto feed head on weed eater sucks. Anyhow, 6 years in and still on original batts, they have degraded but still work for me.