What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
MieleMiele Classic C1 Pure SuctionReddit's pickReddit score
96% positive · 53 opinions
MieleMiele Complete C3 MarinReddit score
95% positive · 40 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Too close to call
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Hard Floors
Maneuverability
Cord
Carpet Head
Durability
Carpet
Build Quality
Suction Control
Cleaning
Summary
The Miele Classic C1 Pure Suction is treated as a hard-floor specialist, and owners who bought it for that are very satisfied: it is amazing on laminate/tile/wood, does a great job on our hardwood and, as one owner puts it, sucks really really hard. Because the wand carries no motor, the stick part is super light and it is Easy to get into weird spaces under furniture. Longevity is a recurring point, with one owner saying after almost six years it still works like new.
Owners of the Miele Complete C3 Marin are largely enthusiastic, often weighing it against the Sebo E3 or D4. One calls it a tank, another says the two brands are top notch and you can’t go wrong either way, and a recent buyer says it really upgraded how clean my floors could get. Favorite features are the automatic suction control and the light on the carpet tool, and one owner notes the auto setting takes the guesswork out of vacuuming.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Miele Classic C1 Pure Suction
Hello, I purchased the Miele Classic C1 canister vacuum, but it doesn't work well on my carpet. Could someone please recommend vacuum cleaners that perform well on both hardwood and carpet? I've attached some pictures of my carpet for reference. My budget is $300
Hi all, I am sorely in need of a new vacuum cleaner. I have all hardwood floors with just a few area rugs, and I have a large dog that sheds an insane amount. I vacuum pretty much daily. I currently have an upright Shark that I absolutely loathe, and I definitely want to switch to a bagged canister vacuum. In the limited research that I’ve done, I’ve seen repeated recommendations for the Miele Classic C1 Pure Suction, but I’ve also seen some pretty negative reviews specifically about its floorhead. Anybody have any insight on this? Or other recommendations that would meet my needs? I’m honestly looking to spend as little as possible while still getting something quality that will hopefully last a good while. The Miele is just over $300 on amazon right now, which feels doable. I could maybe go $400 but really don’t want to go any higher if at all possible. Thanks!
Miele Complete C3 Marin
I recently opened my vac to check the bag. Was shocked to see the compartment full of dust, etc. I replaced the filter that goes into the motor, and used a hand vac to clean the interior as best I could and replaced the bag. Used it again and there was more dust in the compartment but not close to the same extent. I’m assuming it was dust I wasn’t able to get out on my first attempt. I’m not sure if the bag was busted, not clipped in properly or something else. My concern is that the motor will be damaged if I keep running it. I bought locally, a few years ago. Do I need to get it serviced? Is it something I can do myself?
Sebo D4 vs Miele C3 Marin
I'm interested in how you like the D4. I had a Marin and returned it because the LED floor head was just too heavy for me.
Miele Classic C1 Pure Suction
Okay I super fast bought this after a suggestion from someone here. I have finished concrete floors with some large and small area rugs. No pets but we have a toddler and I shed my long hair more than any human I’ve met. I returned my Dyson V10 to Costco and pretty sure I’ll never look back. These are my initial thoughts. If someone who knows a lot about this vacuum has any tips in return I’d love to hear them! Pros: + No. Hair. Wrap!!!!! No more stuck roller brush. I can vacuum like normal, all the hair, and there’s nothing I have to cut out after. (Which I’m lazy so I never really cut it out of my Dyson until it got so bad it wouldn’t function well lol). + I can vacuum essentially forever without the battery running out which as a battery stick vacuum lover this was something I was missing. + The bags and filters actually feel way more sanitary and clean. I can see how overtime the vacuum will not get all gross. Takes 2 seconds to switch. Just keep them stocked. + I was able to vacuum under my whole stove without moving it with the attachment, something I couldn’t do with my Dyson (too fat). That was immensely satisfying. + I hated winding cords on our old vacuums and never did it. The cord winder is huge for me. + I found that my Dyson started to miss some simple crumbs (yes, even after cleaning out the brush roll). I never miss anything after a pass with this except maybe some hairs that are stuck under something. It felt intense with the small attachment😂 + Our concrete floors have (purposeful yet dumb) ~1.25” deep cracks through them. A lot of food and dust get stuck in them. Our Dyson couldn’t vacuum those up unless we used a pick. I was able to vacuum out the majority of stuff in the cracks (except the really jammed in stuff) and that was amazing! Made me realize how much more suction this has. + I have a 5x7 area rug that is pretty thin. I could only vacuum it on the lowest setting with my Dyson or it would jam the brush roll. I can vacuum it on the highest setting with the Miele if I step on an edge and drag it across. That rug has never looked so clean. Cons: - There was a learning curve. It felt weird to vacuum the floor at first with it. But I quickly got used to it. - Definitely tricky on big rugs. It’s hard to push, even on low pile unless you turn the suction down and open that vent thing. I will definitely get the turbo brush roller eventually. But rn I’m poor so it’ll have to wait haha. The set up now is fine short term. - The cord length was totally fine for my needs. I could vacuum the majority of my house and only had to change plugs once (about 1700 sq ft). But others may find that annoying. - The tiny wheels on the vacuum head did get hair wrapped around them lol. Had to pull that out. - Probably the biggest con (next to tricky rug vacuuming but this attachment isn’t even made for that) is just the lack of convenience. It felt so easy to just grab my Dyson off the charger and start vacuuming. It made me vacuum more often. This will be a little more effort (again, lazy cleaner here. I make cleaning easy so I do it more). But in the end I love it! I can see how it will be much easier to maintain and will last so much longer. It really bothered me that our Dyson roller brush was always so tangled with hair and the canister was gross. No hair wrap is MAJOR for me. And yet it feels super powerful. Looking forward to trying the brush roll attachment eventually. I’m wondering if it will collect significantly more than the Dyson from our rugs🤔
Edit: Huge thanks to everyone who took the time to help! After thinking it through, I decided to go with Miele Classic C1 since it offered the best value for the price, plus it’s on discount at the moment. :)) idk what to pick anymore. vacuum cleaner shopping is a mess i'm serious. my old dyson v8 absolute loses suction after 5 mins, battery is toast, 5+ years old, need something for quick pickups and deeper cleans. i'm not trying to cheap out but i'm also not paying extra just for a logo. need something that'll last 3-4 years minimum, replaceable battery would be clutch. skip the sponsored top 10 lists, what do you use?
Highly recommend eBay. I got a Miele Classic C1 Pure Suction PowerLine for $230 that was brand-new as far as I could tell. Does a great job on our hardwood & tile floors.
Miele Complete C3 Marin
Mostly medium height Carpet; cat hair dust seems to be the biggest issues...some hard floor. Is the suction and filtration just as good on the Sebo K3 as Miele C3 or even C1 Turbo. The concern I have with Miele C3 series is people are saying they leak dust even when bag is properly sealed but in videos it does look like Miele suction is better for pet hair etc... I know about the hospital grade S filtration in SEBO and can buy HEPA if desired for the Sebo K3. Severe dust allergies/asthma after vacuuming with my brand new Shark bagless Duo fin pet vacuum... allergy doctor recommend a bagged only vacuum of good quality. I would love to replace my carpet with hard wood floors but cannot afford it right now.
Thanks to too much YouTube and this subreddit I replaced my Shark Apex with a Miele Complete C3 HomeCare Electro+ luckily I got a steal of a deal (I think) at a local shop. I got the C3 with all the normal accessories, the larger floor nozzle, and 3 boxes of bags for 874 before tax
I'm a bit of a vacuum nerd; I own several types and models plus I refurbish and flip Kirby, Sebo, Rainbow, Filter Queen, and others. Both of my C3 models were purchased from FaceBook Marketplace at a steep discount from new. Miele has rolled out their new Guard series of vacuums but there are still deals on the C3s that you should consider; especially the C3 Kona, Cat & Dog, Marin, and HomeCare. Here's my comparison of these two models that I love. 1. C3 Brilliant. The top of the line and these are likely unicorns now at dealers. The color scheme was a collaborative effort with Porsche. It's a very cool, matte bronze finish. Unfortunately, if you scratch or chip it, it can't be polished back to new. These have undercarriage LED lighting that stays on 30 2. seconds after you unplug to light the way back into the closet for storage. The handle features all the controls of the unit, there are no controls on the C3 body except power on and off. There is an auto setting in addition to the standard 4 settings (Curtains, Upholstery, Parquet, & Carpet) and when you 3. dock the wand it will shut off automatically in standby mode so you can move furniture, answer the phone, etc.. The bumper is velvet instead of plastic, and the trim is chromed. These came with the top-of-the-line SEB 236 power nozzle which is slimmer, has an LED light and weighs a little less than the SEB 228. *BTW, the SEB 236 is discontinued, the Guard series only offer the SEB 228 on the two electro models.* The Brilliant includes the AllTeQ floor combo brush and the XL Parquet twister. Pricing on these was @ $1,889 in late 2024. Concerns owning this machine: the paint finish over time will show wear and tear. More concerning: Miele had several issues with wand and hose assembly connections to the power nozzle. If this goes bad, you must purchase a complete handle and hose assembly which costs @ $200. Buyer beware if buying this one used. I found my Brilliant from a retired couple that used it solely for their vacation lake home. This was the husband's pride and joy and only he used it, and he meticulously cared for it. They downsized their homes, selling both the lake house and their primary property to build a new home in a lake community and no longer needed this one. This vacuum was lightly used, showing no signs of wear. However, the SEB 236 was not lowering all the way down due to the carriage assembly catching on a retaining clip. This was a 10-minute repair and now a favorite in the vacuum fleet. I use this machine occasionally and the wand controls really are convenient. 2. Homecare C3. This was a mid-level package for the Tango Red Homecare line. At the low end was a suction-only machine and at the top end was the HomeCare+ (@ $1,600) which included the same automatic controls and SEB 236 as the Brilliant. If you find this HomeCare+, it the same as the Brilliant without all the paint and chrome flourishes. My model HomeCare came with the very durable SEB 228 power nozzle and the 3-piece tool set: 22" crevice tool, SUB 20 large dusting brush and AllTeQ floor brush. In the first photo, I included the standard parquet twister that I added separately to round out the kit. If you find this unit still available at your dealer, especially at a 20-25% discount, this is the one I'd be on the hunt for. I found my HomeCare locally on FaceBook Marketplace but not as well maintained as my Brilliant. It reeked of nicotine, and the SEB 228 had been abused. The C3 body showed signs of moderate use (scratches, furniture marring, etc.) but the interior bag compartment was surprisingly immaculate/dust free. I did a complete tear down and service of the SEB 228, then used degreaser to sanitize and remove the nicotine odor from all components. I ran the machine for an hour with a fresh bag with scent beads to further eliminate the nicotine odor from the interior and let it air out for several days with all compartments open. The hose was hand washed and the interior cleaned using an electrician's fish line and damp rag being careful not to damage the electrical components and then air drying for several days. The exterior of the C3 was polished using the Nexus 3-step compounds with drill bit polishers. Unfortunately, I accidentally polished the finish off the C3's lettering (the raised font is visible if you zoom in). This vacuum is my weekly deep cleaner for all the floors and above the floor cleaning. I use it to detail our cars as well. It’s an incredible workhorse of a vacuum. Final thoughts as the Miele C3 chapter closes and the Guard series is established. The outgoing C3s are a good value compared to the Guard vacuums. The bags are a full quart larger, use the same Hepa filtration, and are reliable units. The Guard series are a little lighter and quieter and of course look "new" but if shopping today, there are deals out there! My vacuum dealer bought a pallet of C3 Marins prior to the release of the Guard series. These units are heavily discounted, and he is saving the last one for me. I am stoked to add the Marin to the collection, probably next month (waiting for my government furlough to get resolved and paychecks to resume). Meanwhile, I'm finishing up and flipping several of my pending refurbished Kirby projects (Sentria II, Avalir and an Avalir 2).