What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
MacMac MTH-80Reddit's pickReddit score
100% positive · 30 opinions
MercerMercer Genesis 8" Chef's KnifeReddit score
95% positive · 36 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Durability
Value
Sharpness
Handle
Pro Use
Edge Retention
Vs Victorinox
Handling
Summary
The Mac MTH-80 (the Mac Professional 8" with dimples) is one of the most consistently praised chef's knives in these discussions. Owners say it comes very sharp out of the box and durable, and that It also holds an edge really well while staying easy to sharpen. One new owner Actually diced an onion properly for the first time. Many call it the best pick at its price: Hands down the best chef knife for the budget.
The Mercer Genesis 8" chef's knife is widely recommended as an entry-level workhorse, with one daily user saying I cannot recommend the Mercer Genesis knives enough. The handle is a highlight: people say it has a much better handle IMO than rivals, and its grip is valued by those who want something with a nonslip handle. Not everyone agrees, as some find it pretty chunky and one owner of the 6" version finds it way too handle heavy.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Mac MTH-80
No complaints found on Reddit yet.
Mercer Genesis 8" Chef's Knife
I have a 6” Mercer genesis chef knife that I got for my wife and I hate the balance on the damn thing. Genesis has a short bolster too. It’s way too handle heavy with the shorter blade, in my opinion, but ymmv. Cheap, though!
Definitely edge retention is important to me. I use my knives all day 5-6 days a week and am constantly frustrated with the lack of retention that I’m currently working with. Also I’m just looking for a very precise and smooth blade. I do a good amount of finesse work. Right now I swap back and forth between using a 8” Mercer Genesis (provided by my culinary school) and a Gesshin stainless 210mm Wa-Gyuto. I love the sturdiness of the Mercer but the precision of the Gesshin. A combo of those two would be ideal.
Hey, just want to chime in here, since I'm currently in culinary school and faced this question myself. When I started, I bought the set that was available in the bookstore, which was Mercer Genesis. The architecture of these knives is pretty similar to Wüsthof in my still-new-to-this opinion. I have a Wüsthof Classic chef knife at home, and it honestly sits pretty unused along with a bunch of those Mercers. Over time, I've replaced the Mercers with Victorinox Pro chef knife, boning knife, and paring knife. They've been serving me a lot better in class, and are cheap enough that you don't have to stress too much about them.
Mac MTH-80
I have a wusthof chef knife and it’s by far the best knife I have ever owned. I had a Mac mighty and it was solid as well but someone walked off with it. I have a Victorinox deboning knife and it’s good as well.
imgur.com/a/Ry27PaO yeeted Mac Pro 10in with drop tip reprofile, full body thin, regrind, re-regrind, dremel skid marks ‘for food release’. Been dropped, lent out, bumped, banged, smashed through a frozen snickers bar. Never complained but took some breaks (;
Mac. All day. MTH-80 is terrific, about 150.00 and there is a set with a pairing knife. I own a lot of knives. This is what I give to starting line cooks who work for me and take their job seriously. He will get a lot of pleasure out of it for years.
Mercer Genesis 8" Chef's Knife
I cannot recommend the Mercer Genesis knives enough for an entry-level quality knife. So comfortable. And with regular honing they stay sharp forever. I’ve used mine daily for 6 years. Cook 2-4 meals a day. Still super sharp. I bought my parents the same set, they never hone, cut stuff on marble countertops and really abuse the knives. I’ll give them a good home when I visit and they are back to being good.
If you’re just graduating from dalstrong, I’d give this advice: Go with a brand that has history in knife making. Research good online marketplaces to scope out what you want to buy, Amazon doesn’t count. Don’t get a knife set. Get knives that allow you to do more, and are diverse from your others in either design, materials, or quality. (I regret having so many knives all of the same steel type) Don’t rush to find the “grail” knife. Learn how to maintain your tools well. Cheap but still an upgrade: kiwi knives. The nakiri bunka combo is lovely Less than a dalstrong: Mercer genesis (love the handles and they perform well out of their class cost wise) Similar dalstrong price: try out a Tojiro gyuto, it’s great for learning to use a whetstone, and it really grows on you over time. It’s one of the best value VG-10 options. In terms of knife type, I see a chefs knife/gyuto missing?? Based on your knife choices meats with bones are on your menu. A boning knife might be a good addition? I don’t know how happy that dalstrong cleaver thing makes you but a Chinese cleaver can be pretty fun as well (tojiro makes one, so does CCK, I personally have the Mercer Chinese cleaver, and never been disappointed in its performance). Good luck! The beginner guide/ intro to the Reddit also has some excellent recommendations on chefs knives/gyuto/cleavers.
Instead of Victorinox, get an 8" Mercer Genesis. It's a damn fine starter beater, similar price, and a much better handle IMO.