What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
KoboKobo Clara BWReddit score
93% positive · 40 opinions
KoboKobo Libra ColourReddit score
90% positive · 75 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Too close to call
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Screen Quality
Page Buttons
Portability
Software & Sideloading
Stylus Notes
Color Covers
Screen Contrast
Library Access
Build Quality
Value
Summary
The Kobo Clara BW gets overwhelmingly warm feedback. Its size is the most-praised trait: owners call it so portable and pocketable, and some who also bought a larger Kobo found the Clara alone fits all my needs. Many chose it over color models for the sharper page; one buyer exchanged the Clara colour for the Clara BW because the color screen was too dark, and text-only readers prefer the better screen contrast by far.
The Kobo Libra Colour is a favourite among people leaving Kindle, and the most common reason is the page turn buttons on the libra color. Owners also like that Kobo's UI is so much organised and clean, the organization I can do in Calibre, and built-in integration with Overdrive, Google Drive, Dropbox. Many say seeing the covers in colour makes me happy, and colour highlighting is a draw: owners enjoy being able to highlight/annotate in different colors. Several call it way snappier and more responsive than the Kindles they came from.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Kobo Clara BW
Unfortunately the warranty doesn't cover physical screen damage. It's a bummer how delicate these things are- just had to replace my clara BW because of screen damage
I broke the screen of my Clara BW 3 weeks after getting it, then decided to get the Clara colour to replace it. I didnt like the fuzziness of the screen too at first, but then after drastically increasing the weight of the font, I slowly got used to it with the perceived improved contrast. Maybe give this a try before you return it?
Look, I like the screen on my KLC, even at 0% brightness. I also don't mind having the brightness up when needed. But BW screens are superior for simply being brighter without any front light. There's just no way around that. The textured appearance I got used to very quickly and don't even notice it anymore. For reference, I had the Clara BW, but decided it was too small for my comfort. I also tried the PW12, but holding it was weirdly cumbersome and distracted me from reading.
Kobo Libra Colour
Some people are just more sensitive to variations in the screen and its lighting than others. Then there are some-- looks like it's mainly the same handful of posters-- who seem to have made it their mission to try to make everyone feel bad about their new purchase. That takes a level of obnoxiousness that I just don't understand. If my Colorsoft arrives tomorrow and the quality of the B&W text on the screen suffers more than I like from the color layer, as was the case with the Kobo Libra Color, or it has a pronounced yellow band that annoys me, I'll be sure to cover that in my review, and then I'll return the device. I won't feel the need to then make dozens of posts per day on threads where people are excited about their new Colorsoft and try to spoil their good time. So if you're enjoying using it, that's all that really matters. Everything else is just white noise.
I started my Kobo journey with a Clara BW last year and bought a KLC this year. The plan was to use the Clara for travel because of its smaller size and the KLC at home. But I am now considering selling the KLC because I barely use it - the Clara alone fits all my needs. I only read novels so don’t need the color for much, but the Clara also fits comfortably in my pocket and is easier to read while traveling and while at home. It also works fine while exercising (on a treadmill or stationary bike) or while lying in bed or on a plane.
I get down voted so much in other subreddits but really at the end of the day the hardware is so much better with kindle vs Kobo. It's pretty night and day between the Kobo Libra colour and the coloursoft. Everything down to contrast and font kerning is better on kindle. I used both brands at different times in my life for years each and I have kindles from 10 yrs ago and they're still great.
Kobo Clara BW
$280 for the kindle color. They aren't going to be able to compete with Kobo. Glad I got a Clara BW
EDIT: Comments are asking for comparison pictures. Here is one I took of all 4 devices at 0% brightness next to a window in daylight. Personally, I couldn’t stand the color screens after comparing them in the day with the BW. Even the Kindle PW was not as contrasted as the Clara BW. preview.redd.it/2x5kxebu3dge1.jpeg?width=4030&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8dd5f70cd18aaa5dea0d3cd4432f5d2337b4c110
I exchanged the Clara colour for the Clara BW because I personally found the color screen way too dark to read with unless the light was on fairly bright, even in daylight. If it were me, I’d go with black and white. It’s a noticeably better experience.
Kobo Libra Colour
I also got fed up with waiting and ordered a Kobo Libra Color, but I LOVE mine. I'm never going back to Kindle. The customization and organization I can do in Calibre is game changing.
Page turn buttons on the libra color. Also just wanting to get away from the Amazon machine a little bit
I can't 😅, I love my libra colour. I don't read comics and don't annotate, I got it for the buttons and seeing the covers in colour makes me happy.