What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
GarminGarmin Enduro 3Reddit score
92% positive · 38 opinions
GarminGarmin Instinct 2XReddit's pickReddit score
96% positive · 44 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Battery Life
MIP Display
Tracking Accuracy
Fenix Alternative
Size
Software
Durability
Smart Features
Flashlight
Summary
The Garmin Enduro 3 is one of the most loved watches in these discussions, with owners calling it the best piece of tech I've ever owned. Battery life is the headline: owners report they only need to charge once every 30 days even with daily training, and one carried it through a full Pacific Crest Trail thru-hike. The always-on MIP screen is the other big draw. People switching from AMOLED Garmins say it is so readable during the day and readable from any angle without a gesture. One owner noticed it is not as crisp indoors as an Instinct 2.
The Garmin Instinct 2X is mostly loved, and battery life is the main reason. Owners describe killer battery life (40 days++), rarely worrying about charging, and with regular sun the solar models can go well over a month. One owner on a five-day hike says theirs made it all 5 days without a single need to charge. The built-in LED flashlight is another favorite, called such a killer feature, and the watch is seen as rugged, built to last through swimming and surfing.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Garmin Enduro 3
You’ll regret it. I had a 955 (so a MIP 965). I just “upgraded” to the Enduro 3. Other than the battery life, I have gained nothing. I mean nothing. For reference, I use the watch to road run, trail run, hike, and record yoga sessions. I use other devices for weight lifting. I use a HRM Pro with all watches because none of them are nearly as accurate or reliable as a chest strap. Maybe you use features or do activities I didn’t have on my 955. Otherwise, nothing meaningful.
preview.redd.it/2ud2zez0tq0e1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e7a3d3a590050f792181d0e519d81675c837272d Here you go! This is what I was talking about. The Enduro 3 is still legible but the contrast is not as crisp as I was expecting coming from the Instinct 2 MIP.
“The current plan is to roll the “new to Garmin” software features that announced with Forerunner 570 and 970 into the Fenix 8 series, Enduro 3 and Tactix 8 in future software releases. We cannot comment on the exact timing or guarantee that all features will make it into these updates.” So my Enduro 3 that costs 900 bucks and that i bought last december will now maybe not even get new features? Yeah fuck no
Garmin Instinct 2X
I'm clocking in 5 weight lifting sessions a week plus a number of runs and walks and I couldn't care less about Garmin nowadays (this is coming from a Fenix 5 and an Instinct 2X Solar). It does depend on what you value, but if we're being honest, the smart functions of Garmin are way behind.
Keep in mind screen and text size. I'm 76 and have trouble reading sms notifications on my Instinct 2x with mip. AMOLED on my 47mm Epix is a little better.
I had an Instinct 1 and upgraded to an Instinct 2X. I can't say I'm that happy with the upgrade so I can't recommend it. The HR sensor is not good at reading interval efforts, it still has the same crumb trails instead of actual navigation and doesn't track altitude changes well in the mountains. The battery is nice though. I don't care much about the Garmin specific statistics (body battery, training readiness, etc..) anymore so I will be switching to the COROS PACE Pro for my next upgrade. It's cheaper, same amount of battery, better navigation, better sensors and overall seems to be working better. I used to be a Garmin fan, but lately I feel the price no longer reflects the quality. Take this advice as you will.
Garmin Enduro 3
Sportswatch vs smartwatch. They are not the same. Can you take a call on this? Can you reply to text messages?Do you have LTE? Can you download apps? Do you have mic to talk to smart assistant? Does it call SOS automatically if you fall? There much more Apple Watch can to that this sportwatch can. Just because it have bluetooth and notifications it does not mean it is a smartwatch. Not hating garmin have enduro 3 and love it but people compare two different watches
Enduro 3. Owned for a year. Never charged it. Still has 30 percent 🤣🤣🤣
I prefer MIP to amoled. Love my enduro 3, screen is so readable during the day. The battery life is the best only need to charge once every 30 days with heavy usage everyday for 2-3 hours
Garmin Instinct 2X
Looks like a watch for kids that can shoot small nerf darts. Love my instinct 2x but the 3 is a hard pass
As smartwatches go, Garmin watches are extremely resilient. If you want something that will last a long time with good battery health and kinda timeless in terms of usage and software experience your best option probably is in the Instinct line. I had an Apple Watch Ultra, but it just didn’t felt right for me (personal preference, the watch itself is really good) so I sold it and bought an Instinct 2X Solar. Extremely happy with my first Garmin and I haven’t missed the Apple Watch for a single second. The Apple Watch is good at doing everything and it’s arguably the most feature rich smartwatch, but Garmin watches are like finely crafted and well tuned tools that excel at specialized tasks for any particular discipline.
Garmin keeps updated products with more activities etc but how many owners actually use them to their full function? I have an Epix Gen 2 and an Instinct 2x. I wear the Instinct more than the Epix because I use the flashlight a good bit. The Fenix 8 looks nice but for the price it's just more of the same with voice function but no LTE. Lotta smoke no ham.