What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
DellDell U4025QWReddit's pickReddit score
95% positive · 42 opinions
ASUSASUS XG27UCDMGReddit score
92% positive · 44 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Sharpness
Productivity
Motion Handling
Image Quality
Thunderbolt Dock
Glossy Coating
IPS Black
Size & Curve
Burn-In
Value
Summary
The Dell U4025QW is overwhelmingly recommended as a work-first ultrawide. Developers, writers and analysts call it an amazing home office monitor, and the 5K2K resolution gives a 40-inch screen extra height that people value: 5k2k is very good for productivity. Text is a highlight, with one heavy data user saying older OLEDs don't stand a chance next to the text clarity, and the built-in Thunderbolt dock, KVM and daisy-chaining make it 5k thunderbolt dock boasting, daisychain cable decluttering majesty.
The ASUS XG27UCDMG is a 27-inch 4K 240Hz QD-OLED, essentially the display port 1.4 version of the PG27UCDM with the same panel, and owners are strongly positive. Sharpness stands out: buyers coming from 1440p say the difference is night and day, that text and image sharpness is out of this world, and praise the truly insane pixel density sharpness. Others call it the Best image quality I’ve ever witnessed, with great sdr and hdr on windows.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Dell U4025QW
More pics of monitors on my 72x30 desk: imgur.com/a/VXWP0Z0 My last post got flagged since it violated the "no box pictures" rule, so here we go again, with a 4th monitor this time. TL;DR = 57" Neo G9 -> 38" AW3821DW -> 49" G9 (2024 version, non Mini-LED) -> 40" U4025QW, what next? Coming from a dual 24" 1920x1200 monitors for past 20 years with an added 3rd 24" FHD 5 years ago that was primarily used for media viewing and webinars. Decided to go on a widescreen journey, they sounded appealing. I am 100% productivity use. Here is the order I went through these monitors and my opinions on them: * 57" Neo G9 - Used for 5 weeks, decided it was just too physically wide for my liking (nothing to do with resolution, just physical dimension). I also used it on Bewiser arm which got it further away from me but opinion still the same. Curve is great, VA viewing angles bad. Returned to Best Buy. * 38" AW3821DW - Needs more curve. Same horizontal resolution as 2x24" but being a single screen lets you get 3 windows across which is a nice upgrade, plus the extra vertical resolution, but I can't make all 3 windows the width I'd like. With a few hundred pixels more width it would be much better. This one doesn't make sense to me as my only monitor, but paired with a second monitor, maybe it would make more sense. Still have monitor on hand, for now. * 49" G9 - Compared to the 57", it didn't feel too wide, more "just right" size wise. Has enough resolution to do 4 full width monitors across the width, which is great, but less vertical resolution than the 38". Curve great, VA viewing angles bad. Rather awful backlight evenness and bleed. Still have on hand, for now. * 40" U4025QW - Needs more curve. IPS black is nice. Running at 125% scaling and it has that little bit extra horizontal resolution I wanted in the 38" so I can run my 3 windows all my desired width, and I has even more height than the 38". I can run it at 120% at same viewing distance but doesn't really gain much by doing so. If I bring it a decent amount closer to my face, I can run at 110-115% which opens up into the 4 windows across territory, but it's just too flat to have that close to me. I don't like non-integer scaling in windows, so that plus the flatness are downers for me on this monitor. At the moment, I like the 49" best. 1440px vertical is still an upgrade from my 24" monitors, although not as good as 1600px of 38" or 1728px of the 40". With my eyes and preferred viewing distance, I can't see the difference in 109 PPI and 139 PPI, so that doesn't really give the 40" any upside to me. Going to use the Dell for another day or two but I kind of doubt I stick with it. I'm thinking about trying a 34" + LG DualUp or 38" with one of my 24" in portrait. I've never been a fan of non-symmetric monitor setups, so not sure if I really want to go down this road. Also considering swapping G9 to Neo G9 for better backlight. It would cost $350 more though and most of the time I'm not dealing with dark windows where the G9's bad backlight is a big factor. I know it would be an odd aspect ratio, but give me something 49" or close to it, 1000R, IPS Black, 5120x1600 to 5120x2160 (maybe little wider pxl) and it would be perfect for me. The LG 45" 5K OLED that is coming may be something I have to try out. I don't really want OLED but 45" 5K might be just big enough to run without needing scaling like I do on the 40", and I'm sure it will have an aggressive curve as well.
I tried the Dell U4025QW and it was great, until I noticed the poor motion handling, then it was all I could see. Really hope for a good 5120x2160
The U4025QW has the worst blur i've ever seen. I was running it at 5k 120hz, and just scrolling websites was so infuriating. Ended up returning it and going back to my LG 38GL950. Going to wait until December-ish for that 45 inch 5k oled on the roadmap.
ASUS XG27UCDMG
I agree I have a XG27UCDMG and that's my main gripe is really having to \*think\* more about being extra careful with it. I've mainly noticed a decent amount of microscratches and finish issues on one side of the bezel just from using a microfiber cloth on a stubborn piece of monitor grime. Like, my display is fine in-general; still looks like Day 1 - but that experience alone just makes me anxious about cleaning it if I have a rogue sneeze etc. I've never noticed finish damage like that on anything other than PSVR2 lenses from my eyelashes. OLED, Mini-LED VA, LCD etc just seem more resiliant - not sure if it's related to just glossy versus matte finishes though
Yeah but it's MUCH better than on QD-OLEDs. Here's my XG27UCDMG 4th Gen QD-OLED vs my XG27AQWMG Tandem W-OLED. Even in normal room lighting the QD-OLED starts turning purple and gets pretty bad with direct light. Whereas the W-OLED fares much better. In my experience the True Black Glossy Coating is still better than the Semi-Glossy coating of QD-OLEDs. Even the new Quantum Black film 5th Gen QD-OLEDs have still have worse black level raise than the True Black Glossy coating of W-OLEDs. preview.redd.it/8nkt279iqwvh1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a9ac52bda2358f94902219760af6c7314228f88f
It's definitely gonna depend on your lighting. I've tried the XG27AQWMG Tandem W-OLED and coating is honestly so good. In my room my current XG27UCDMG turns purple in normal lighting. My biggest pet peeve so far. First 2 photos are the UCDMG. Last one is the AQWMG. preview.redd.it/glux0r912tvh1.jpeg?width=3072&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=095eaed0d654a52a57771b65c6950fa7bc5948ec
Dell U4025QW
Don't know what your budget is, but I returned the OLED G9 and got the Dell U4025QW and it has been so worth it
Budget open? Dell U4025QW. An amazing home office monitor with good gaming capabilities (to be honest haven’t had any issues with gaming). I love mine.
For me the problem with a 49" productivity monitor is the lack of height. I felt much better with the 40" Dell U4025QW for work.
ASUS XG27UCDMG
You were right, OP great choice. All OLEDs have banding, even QD-OLEDs, but it’s much less pronounced on those. Mine is a 4th-gen QD-OLED, the XG27UCDMG from ASUS. preview.redd.it/zmrf0lwhiojg1.jpeg?width=2000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=28a9e8b4956c506ab23dc7baa7c161b489670c88 95% grey
I upgraded from the Gigabyte M27U to the XG27UCDMG earlier this year, and I have no regrets. I really like 27-inch 4K displays; they look great.
I have the XG27UCDMG and I'm loving it. Though, it is my first OLED so I don't have a lot to compare to. The True Black Glossy monitors do look interesting to me as well. You won't be upset with the XG27UCDMG and I doubt you'll be upset with the upcoming monitor tech either. There is always going to be new tech coming out so either you eventually make the decision to get something or you'll be waiting forever. If I were in your position, I would wait because it isn't much longer before them come out. But if they were coming out in the fall or winter timeframe, I'd pull the trigger on something now.