What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
CarlinkitCarlinkit Mini UltraReddit's pickReddit score
65% positive · 69 opinions
MotorolaMotorola MA1Reddit score
50% positive · 1,091 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
Connection Stability
Durability
Dropouts
Setup
Features
Startup Time
Compact Size
Startup Speed
Price
Overheating
Summary
The Carlinkit Mini Ultra is a tiny plug-in wireless CarPlay and Android Auto adapter, and its size is the first thing owners mention: it has no cable, just plugs in and barely sticks out of the port. Many say it boots and connects quickly, with comments like it starts and connects very very fast, and a good share of owners report months of trouble-free use across cars from Corolla and CX-5 to VW and Kia head units, calling it rock solid for me. It is cheap, especially from the official AliExpress store, where owners mention paying around $10 to $20.
The Motorola MA1 is one of the most frequently recommended wireless Android Auto adapters, and a large share of owners say it simply works, every time. Setup is usually a literal plug and play, and once paired it automatically connects when I turn on the car, with reported startup times ranging from about 5 seconds to it took 26 seconds or more. Several people who struggled with AAWireless found the MA1 much, much, much more stable, and households with two drivers like that a press of the side button lets it switch to the other paired phone.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
Carlinkit Mini Ultra
Mini Ultra is buggy. Mini Ultra 3 works flawlessly.
Thank you for this review!! I’ve been using the Mini Ultra (original) for the last 6 months and it constantly disconnects or stutters during use. It’s been driving me crazy. Based on your recommendation, I ordered the new Mini Ultra 3 and it was delivered yesterday. I was in the car for a few hours yesterday with the Mini Ultra 3 and it ran flawlessly. Not one single issue!!! Thank you again!!
Thanks for this. I have had the Carlinkit 5.0 mini ultra (as opposed to the Carlinkit mini ultra 3 you speak of) and was having pretty good luck with it until quite recently. Got a new iPhone 17 pro with plenty of storage (so no memory issues) and Updated the firmware…but yeah like others have said I’m getting cut off every 20 minutes or so with plenty of skipping/lagging when it DOES work. Hopefully the carlinkit mini ultra 3 solves my problem.
Motorola MA1
I spent so much time trying to get the Motorola MA1, the AAWireless, and the Ottocast to work well with Android Auto - they don't work well at all. Constant lag, random disconnects; pretty frustrating. The fourth one I tried was the CarlinKit, and it's been a game changer. It simply just works, every time I turn on my car without drops, lag, and all the headache that the other ones brought me.
I have had two AAwireless, a Motorola MA1, and another one (I forget the name, was another kickstarter that is in production now)... In using them all, the AAwireless seems to be WAY better than the others. More configurable and gets around weird issues some headunits/vehicles have, and can get around some of those nasty Android Auto "safety" restrictions like trying to scroll or tap to much. Well worth the extra couple bucks over the others in my opinion.
I would recommend an AAwireless Two instead of the MA1 or the device you're looking at. AAwireless Two is currently only Android but there is a multi version coming out soon. AAwireless has always been considered the best and at £43 a good price.
Carlinkit Mini Ultra
Carlink Mini Ultra - no cable, just plugs in and only sticks out 3/4”! Been using for 6 weeks now - priceless!
I'm assuming you mean wireless CarPlay adapter. I have gone through my fair few and hand my share of them. All of the ones i got off amazon were fine for a month or two then got very temperamental and were returned. I also found that they didnt work if it was too cold or too hot. I then got a Carlinkit Mini Ultra and i have had 0 issues with this so far (3 months) it starts up first time 9/10 times. I think a lot of it has to do with your MMI box type, mine is VAG and they are notorious for playing up. You can get the Carlinit ones off AliExpress for a lot cheaper than off other sites and they are genuine.
So you don't have a USB port under the armrest (in the box) that's labeled as a smartphone port? If you do, it would be enough to update the firmware of the Connect system to at least version 70. 74 is the latest version. I drive a 2019 CX-5 and use a wireless USB dongle (CarLinkIt Mini Ultra) to connect to Android Auto/CarPlay. Works perfectly.
Motorola MA1
I use the Motorola MA1 with good results. I leave it plugged in and a few seconds after I start my Jeep it connects. I have Coolwalk too.
I finished my initial testing: Fixed cable (11cm total \[end of case to end of USB\], 7cm of the bendy part of the wire) is a bit annoying. In my vehicle (Kia Telluride) the adapter has to hang off the port putting unneeded strain on the cable, adapter, and my USB port. imgur.com/a/uPdtojl Setup is easy: 1. Plug in the adapter wait for it to blink blue 2. Pair your phone to adapter over BT 3. Finish on screen setup for AA After setup it'll automatically connect if in range on power up. The AA connection hasn't shown any lag and everything works as if I was wired. The button on the side of the adapter can be used to pair BT devices, Factory rest the adapter, and SWITCH BETWEEN DEVICES!!! A single push of the button will let you switch between paired phones. It takes a little while to switch but it works well. I switched back and forth several times and saw no issues over multiple power cycles of the adapter. I ran into a few weird issues with the adapter (resetting itself a few times on 3rd power on for example). I factory reset the adapter 6 times and that seems to have cleared every issue I had including connectivity issues with my Pixel 6 Pro. If you are having issues with the adapter, I would just do a few factory resets of the adapter and see if that clears your problems. From plugging in the device to getting the AA displayed on my car's screen it took 26 seconds. Tested with: * Pixel 6 Pro * Pixel 5a * Pixel 3 * 2020 Kia Telluride SXP A few people asked so here is a break down of the difference between the MA1 and the AAWireless: AAWireless vs MA1: * MA1 has button that can be used to switch phones; AAW does not so harder to swap * MA1 has a short fixed cable; AAW has detachable USB-C cable. Some like the cable being fixed, I don't and it's too short (11cm total, 7cm for bendable wire section) * AAW has a companion app which allows for updates (new features) and changing settings such as forcing DPI to get AA Split screen; MA1 does not have a companion app and no extra features * MA1 can be purchased through Amazon (at least in US); AAW ships international but through indiegogo * AAW: $85USD ; MA1: $89.95USD \---- Original Post below ---- A bit disappointed the cable is not detachable considering how short it is..... Comes with a sticky gel pad which is nice. The instructions say the button is for Bluetooth pairing and reset so I'm hoping it might be usable for easy phone switching! If anyone has any specific questions I'll be testing it out later tonight. Edit: I ran into some issues that I think are related to my phone so I am going to factory rest it tonight and do additional testing tomorrow. Cable length: 11cm total (end of case to end of USB), 7cm of the bendy part of the wire. I did try with a USB extension and it worked fine (YMMV based on cable). The fixed cable is more annoying than I was expecting as its just too short for it to be able to rest on the section of the car that sits under where it hangs. So far connecting to it really is easy just pair to it over BT and it'll connect. Everything within AA worked well and wasn't lagy so far. After being setup it takes roughly 15 - 20 seconds to boot up and be displaying AA on my car. I will actually time it accurately tomorrow.
I got so sick of the random disconnects I bout the Motorola wireless android auto dongle and just use the USB cable to charge if I need to.