What Reddit owners say about each, side by side — scores, recurring themes and the most-upvoted complaints.
arboleafarboleaf Body WeightReddit's pickReddit score
97% positive · 20 opinions
EtekcityEtekcity ESF-551Reddit score
100% positive · 12 opinions
In short
Head to head
Reddit score
Positive share, discounted when few people weigh in
Positive sentiment
Share of opinions that are positive
Opinions
Mentions that take a side — the evidence behind the score
Mentions
Every relevant Reddit post and comment
Themes
How often each topic comes up, coloured by how owners feel about it.
App & Sync
Body Composition
Consistency
Price
Value
Accuracy
Summary
The arboleaf smart scale is popular with people tracking weight loss who want more than a single number. Owners like that it breaks results into body fat, muscle, bone and water, and many admit they can't say the arboleaf is 100% accurate but find it consistent enough to follow trends. One owner says it tracks my weight extremely well and gives the same reading if you step off and on again.
The Etekcity ESF-551 is a budget smart scale that owners are very happy with, mostly for its app. The free VeSync app has way more information than I was expecting, and users say it syncs to all my other apps including Apple Health, supports unlimited users, and can even be added to Home Assistant over Bluetooth. One owner likes that it stores weigh-ins and lets you choose which to keep when you next open the app.
Owners' words
The most-upvoted Reddit comments about each model.
arboleaf Body Weight
Arboleaf smart scale. But it’s just super rough estimates. I wouldn’t prioritize it over a basic weight only scale tbh
Etekcity ESF-551
No complaints found on Reddit yet.
arboleaf Body Weight
Yeah it’s a scale from amazon called arboleaf. You get on it day one or whenever you start and each measurement it shows all the changes in your body. It’s not expensive either. Theme parks are amazing… i actually forgot but I went thorpe park in england and got on colossus and the should bar wouldn’t close so I had to remove my jacket in the rain in front of a girl i was dating to get it to close or I had to get off because I was too fat. Nowdays I can get on no drama and I feel so good for it. Those small wins are amazing.
I have garmin connect but apparently haven’t been using it to the fullest. Anyone have some quick tips to check out? I mostly lift and do cardio, HIIT type exercises and track my food with the MFP connection. I recently got the renphro food scale and body measuring tape. They all sync together, as it does with my arboleaf scale I’ve had for years. I can’t say the arboleaf is 100% accurate (tells you BMI, muscle mass, fat %, etc) but it is consistent. I got these three things because I tend to underestimate my portions and hold on to a TON of water. I am trying to better understand how my body changes compared to weight on the scale (e.g weight goes up but measurements down).
Oh, I think you're using Arboleaf weighing scale, a great scale to track weight loss, body fat, muscle loss etc.. this is my 1 month result with Mounjaro so far preview.redd.it/1bb96p1spslg1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a6e7757ceb64d070ad954b78bf74ba2ef19ed5cf
Etekcity ESF-551
Thank you! ❤️ It's the Etekcity ESF-551. I LOVE it! Especially with the helpful stats it gives me on my weight. But it's my first smart scale, so I wouldn't know how it compares to others 😅 haha
Ended up ordering a scale from Amazon, that connect to the app you see before you. Did a LOT of testing with it on myself and my wife (who has a substantially smaller and more petite shape) and it is quite accurate for us. Name of the scale is... "Etekcity Smart Scale for Body Weight FSA HSA Store Eligible, Bathroom Digital Weighing Scale with BMI, Body Fat, Muscle Mass, Accurate Bluetooth Home User Health Equipment Sync Apps"
I've used two Etekcity brand scales from Amazon since 2018. The newer of them for the last couple of years: (www.amazon.ca/dp/B095YJW56C?ref\_=ppx\_hzsearch\_conn\_dt\_b\_fed\_asin\_title\_2&th=1) Reasonably priced and no issues.